Re:Universe's expansion may be understood without dark energy
by gjm11 on Monday October 24, 2011 @10:55AM
(#3149858)
Actual paper at author's web site: http://www.helsinki.fi/~aannila/arto/light.pdf. I have to say that a brief perusal sets off my crank alarms, although the author does appear to be a real physicist. ... Oh. On googling a bit more, I find that the author has also claimed a proof that P != NP [EDITED to add: available at http://arxiv.org/abs/0906.1084]. The signs aren't looking good.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Universe's expansion may be understood without dark energy
by lutorm on Monday October 24, 2011 @12:34PM
(#3150322)
a brief perusal sets off my crank alarms
That's what I was going to say, too. And I got more convinced the further down I got. The weird, convoluted wording was a big tipoff. And then this sealed it:
When a star explodes and its mass is combusted into radiation, conservation requires that the number of quanta stays the same, whether in the form of matter or radiation.
There is no conservation law limiting the number of photons. This is obviously observed any time you turn on a light bulb.
Re:Universe's expansion may be understood without dark energy
by splat on Monday October 24, 2011 @03:32PM
(#3151173)
If I were being charitable I might think that he was referring to conservation of baryon number or lepton number...but all other indicators point to him not knowing what he's talking about. I'm actually pretty surprised that this paper was accepted. MNRAS is a fairly prestigious journal.
Re:Universe's expansion may be understood without dark energy
by lutorm on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @02:35PM
(#3155249)
That would take a significant amount of charitability (?) since he says
...whether in the form of matter or radiation
Re:Universe's expansion may be understood without dark energy
by splat on Monday October 24, 2011 @11:15AM
(#3149946)
Another good rule of thumb is not to put too much stock in any papers typeset in Microsoft Word rather than LaTeX (as this one was). Perhaps I'll give it a closer look if it ever gets any citations, but I wouldn't put much money on that happening.
Re:Universe's expansion may be understood without dark energy
by tzs on Monday October 24, 2011 @09:36PM
(#3152389)
Considering that some top journals (such as Nature and Science) require or recommend Word format, your rule of thumb is ridiculous.
Re:Universe's expansion may be understood without dark energy
by splat on Tuesday October 25, 2011 @03:41PM
(#3155552)
In astronomy, anyway, LaTeX is the default. It's probably different in other fields which is why the broader journals use Word.