News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In College, Working Hard to Learn High School Material by Jach on Monday October 24, 2011 @10:15AM (#3149660)
Have you done market testing to see how many people out there actually need to start from 2+2? One of my peeves about many programming books is their half-assed attempts at assuming you know nothing and wasting the first 100 or so pages covering introductory material. I appreciate hierarchal approaches, but even in math they don't work so well. Math knowledge is organized in a graph, not a tree.

Do you think a student could pass the AP Calculus BC exam, using only your 60 pages of Calculus as a reference? Would a student be able to go through 1st grade to 12th grade using nothing but your book? If not, why would I buy your book?

I still want to see "The Simple Math of Everything" http://lesswrong.com/lw/l7/the_simple_math_of_everything/

Re:In College, Working Hard to Learn High School Material by ivan_ah on Monday October 24, 2011 @11:06AM (#3149901)
> how many people need to start from 2+2

The basic math sections in the book are quite fast. The intent was not so much to teach/drill/annoy the reader with the high school stuff, but to have a self-contained book, instead of saying "complete the square which you should know from high school".

> you think a student could pass the Calculus using only your 60 pages of Calculus as a reference?

Honestly, yes. But my belief is unimportant here -- I have to test things out with real students and real exams.

> 1st grade to 12th grade

A student no, but an adult who doesn't remember that stuff yes.