I guess I'm unreasonable, but, if you're looking for data points: hi, I'm a candidate who will turn you down cold if you require school information from me.
For a long time, I thought this was a New York thing, but, no; I got an offer from a very excellent NY tech/finance company a few years before we started Matasano, and nobody there was dumb enough to want to see my report cards.
The first one is reasonable. The second one isn't, and in my opinion is also a waste of time.
I agree, asking "where'd you go to school" isn't particularly offensive.
When all I have to go on is education and a one-year failed startup, I'm going to ask at least a few questions about school. Even then, the startup is more useful.
Maybe they've learned from past mistakes? Or their model can't handle NA values on some features?
I think it reasonable to require a transcript for new graduates.