Re:Poll/Form: What is your religion?
by cpt1138 on Sunday October 23, 2011 @07:43PM
(#3147659)
Atheism is a religion like bald is a hair color
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, esp. a personal God or gods.
Details of belief as taught or discussed.
Atheism (movement regardless) is the strict belief that a god does not exist; hence a religion.
Agnosticism/Non-religious is more not a religion.
By that argument, a belief that Santa Claus (as an actual being who lives at the North Pole and on Christmas Eve delivers toys to all the good children) does not exist is a religion.
Santa Claus is pre-determined to not exist; and as far as human culture is concerned Deities are not pre-determined to be non-existent.
Though yes, there is the strict belief that santa claus does not exist and that is a belief.
Atheism is a religion because people who self-declare atheism are normally people who strictly believe that no deities exist.
Either way, whether is a religion or non-religion, it is something people cite as their religious views, hence the inclusion of it in this form.
I think you'd find it pretty difficult to find an atheist who claims to strictly know with any kind of certainty that no gods/creators/things outside the universe exist (except maybe Hawking, but he's definitely not representative). Sure, plenty of people claim to know with certainty that specific religions are false, but there's a big difference between the two that is often confused and glossed over by people making the argument you're making.
Correct, but the survey has to have some option to specify non-belief so I think it's valid to include it as a choice. It's like saying: "Religion: none" and null is technically a valid value in this case.