News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lamer News by FreakLegion on Sunday October 23, 2011 @05:14PM (#3147273)
As to your 1.: Let's assume you're being honest and it isn't sock puppetry. It's still basically astroturfing, and I, at least, don't want to see that here.

If entire communities are allowed to flock to Hacker News to upvote the latest post about their pet platform, the site will become nothing more than a cheap marketing tool.

So, PSA: Please don't strip-mine this community's goodwill for your own or your company's benefit.

As to your 2.: You're entirely correct.

Re:Lamer News by jarek on Sunday October 23, 2011 @09:13PM (#3147871)
"If entire communities are allowed to flock to Hacker News to upvote the latest post about their pet platform, the site will become nothing more than a cheap marketing tool."

Because there's been none of that happening for the past year...

Re:Lamer News by viraptor on Monday October 24, 2011 @06:01AM (#3148918)
I guess you missed the month of erlang posts that were posted because community was asked to post and upvote them?... How is that different exactly?
Re:Lamer News by FreakLegion on Monday October 24, 2011 @11:20PM (#3152689)
What an odd series of replies. Surely you all realize that:

1) Whether astroturfing does happen has no bearing on whether it should happen,

and

2) Examples of people astroturfing are an argument for having the rule, not an argument against it.

Right? Bueller?

Re:Lamer News by luser001 on Monday October 24, 2011 @03:45PM (#3151236)
What? You don't think articles are being systematically upvoted by groups of people? Sorry, I am a realist and it definitely seems like they're being upvoted.

HN is now the tech news site for insiders. It's not some obscure backwater.