Here's an amusing blow-by-blow comparison of the Newton to the iPhone:
http://crave.cnet.co.uk/gadgets/apple-newton-vs-apple-iphone...
Apple's Newton was "a win" for Apple in the sense that it proved the viability of the PDA as a category and, like I said, pioneered all these new concepts - doing things more elegantly or impressively in a smaller package than had been done before. I still miss some of the features Newton had and hope one day to get a product that brings them back.
(FWIW, I worked in the Newton Systems Group on the 2.x operating system and wrote the paint program NewtPaint)
How important is that? Well almost 30 years later, HP still sells the 12C. And the margin is astronomical.
[http://www.amazon.com/HP-12c-Financial-Calculator-12C/dp/B00...]
Despite the difficulty I have of foregoing snark in a case where Scully's projects are deemed an Apple win; when it comes to the Newton: Apple != Jobs.
Keep in mind that both pen computing and digital organizers predate the Newton by several years - my sister had a RadioShack PC1 years before the Newton.
[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pen_computing#History]
[http://www.trs-80.com/wordpress/trs-80-computer-line/pocket/]