News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Which would be a better splash page?

After receiving some mixed feedback on my previous splash page, I put together another one. I was hoping to get some feedback on it.

Option 1: http://www.mesmira.com (the new one, high-level concept and some explanatory pitch text)

Option 2: http://www.mesmira.com/splash (a screenshot of the actual product with the value proposition as text markers)

Option 3: not good enough. Again!

Any suggestions/feedback would be highly appreciated.

Thanks, Aditya

( 7 comments | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Which would be a better splash page? by bayouborne on Sunday October 23, 2011 @09:21AM (#3146050)
Hi Aditya - just my opinion, but I like the 2nd one. The only thing I'd change with the 2nd is the visual treatment of the buttons along the top - they seem a little crowded.

Slightly tweaked version here:

http://www.djconsultants.com/mes2.jpg

Re:Ask HN: Which would be a better splash page? by adityar on Sunday October 23, 2011 @09:32AM (#3146077)
Thanks. This is embarrassing but I can't make out any difference in mes2...I'm looking at the buttons (assume that's where the tweaks are). Is there a change in aspect ratio of the buttons?
Re:Ask HN: Which would be a better splash page? by bayouborne on Sunday October 23, 2011 @10:00AM (#3146129)
It's there, but it's not a very big change - perhaps best chalked up to my obsessiveness to white-space..;-)

Anyway, 2nd's my vote. Good luck!

Re:Ask HN: Which would be a better splash page? by pxtreme75 on Sunday October 23, 2011 @11:09AM (#3146249)
Visually I prefer the first. You need to find a way to keep it as visually pleasing as it is while integrating some more info about the actual product. But I would avoid the second screen -- too complex for a newcomer.
Re:Ask HN: Which would be a better splash page? by adityar on Sunday October 23, 2011 @12:39PM (#3146501)
Thanks for taking the time on this one.
Re:Ask HN: Which would be a better splash page? by seb_z_lite on Sunday October 23, 2011 @11:50AM (#3146366)
I also find the second one too crowded for a splash page. It looks more like a page that I would see as an introduction. A More in-depth exploration of the site.(with animation and fireworks!!).
Re:Ask HN: Which would be a better splash page? by adityar on Sunday October 23, 2011 @12:38PM (#3146496)
Thanks for the feedback. Really appreciate it.