News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @03:01AM (#31455870)
I'll add my own data point into the mix. I'm 49, have been married for 22 years, with kids who are either grown up, or well on their way. Throughout my life though, I have been an absolute loner in spirit. I grew up quite isolated, in the UK countryside, and learned to amuse myself early on. My first love was computers, which luckily has served me fairly well, career-wise. I haven't had many girlfriends, and felt very aware of this lack. When I met my wife, I married her more rapidly than I should have, if I'm honest. I had no confidence in myself regarding my ability to form intimate attachments to women, and thought something like "well if I'm married, then that's that problem sorted!". Not so much.

Still, we've persevered, and made it work for 22 years. But I will soon be 50, and have chosen to view this round number as significant. I would like to start living life as I would like it, both career and relationship wise, and am currently trying to plan out what shape that might take. The stories and information in the comments here, are truly fascinating to me, the breadth of ideas being mentioned are a real breath of fresh air, and a great example of what makes Hacker News great (in my view), so thank you everyone.

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by lr4444lr on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:23AM (#31457249)
Strong predictors of good and bad marriage partners do exist, but I'd caution you against making yourself, wife, and children unhappy for thinking the grass will be greener by blowing up your marriage. Divorce courts have seen many a couple who thought they were star crossed lovers bitterly at one another's throats. Human beings all have flaws that become painfully apparent once you move in with them and thr "honeymoon" phase of the relationship is over. If your spouse supports you emotionally, respects you, and is dependable, you have something not so easy to come by. If your kids are grown, maybe you just need some time alone to get away? Talk to her about it.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:36AM (#31457321)
Thank you for your advice, and I take your point about the divorce courts, but please don't think that we haven't talked. The opposite is very much the case.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by david38 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:16PM (#31463569)
Often it isn’t because the grass is greener somewhere else.

There are cases where the grass looked green, but upon marriage, you discovered it false. Cheating, publicly showing off said cheating (yet hiding it from you), no respect, all manner of things can be uncovered.

If the idea of a normal girl sounds like a step up, I wouldn’t sit tight.

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by ericmay on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:28AM (#31457276)
Please talk to a therapist or counselor before making any decisions. It sounds like you need someone to help talk through emotions, your plans, your desires, etc, and a trained professional will be able to help here. It’s not a sign of weakness, and these people really can help you make great decisions and really iron out what it is that you want, what the costs are for different decisions, etc. and there isn’t much to lose, only more information and better decision making to be gained.

Think of it like hiring a coach. Lebron James has a coach. Tia Toomey has a coach. The worlds most successful business leaders have coaches. It’s alright to hire one who can work with you on making your life better. Best of luck!

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:40AM (#31457343)
That's great advice - I had a therapist for a couple of years, but stopped during covid. I think I will try to find another though - 100% worth it, as you say.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by jjfoooo6 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:29AM (#31458747)
Consider also a couples therapist, all the same rationale applies.

In either case, read up on the process for finding one that works you (and maybe your partner). Make sure it's someone you respect. There's a wide variety in quality, and if it's someone who you do not take seriously it will not be a good use of time.

Good luck

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:53AM (#31458945)
Thank you very much for your replies to what I said - it's good advice, and I'm grateful you would take the time to offer it!
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by jes on Saturday May 21, 2022 @10:11AM (#31458090)
I am 62. About fifteen years ago I could have written almost exactly what you have written above. I blew up my long term marriage because of my fucked up thinking. It was a horrible mistake and one that I regret essentially every day.

Of course, maybe it's all different for you. I mean that. I'm only suggesting something to check.

Have a look at the material under "Nice Guy Syndrome" by Dr. Robert Glover. [1] Maybe get his audio book "No More Mr. Nice Guy" and listen to it for a bit, and see how well it fits or does not fit your situation.

[1] https://drglover.com

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by sillysaurusx on Saturday May 21, 2022 @10:47AM (#31458359)
The flip side is that you know now that it was a mistake. Would you still be happy today if you hadn’t left, but without knowing it was the right choice?

Happiness is a fickle thing.

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by goldenkey on Sunday May 22, 2022 @03:18AM (#31465723)
Isn't this just gonna result in stories based on survivorship bias? Those who put it all on red and won, aren't going to have the same experience as those who lost.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:51AM (#31458928)
I'm sure I fit that "Nice Guy Syndrome" profile to a considerable extent. I'll take a look at the audio book. Thanks a lot for the advice!
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by denton-scratch on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:40AM (#31458839)
/me 65, two kids, two grandkids, two marriages, each of about 15 years. Both times the wife divorced me, rather than vv. (and no doubt that says something about me). Both times the relationship was rocky, but I would have stuck it out were it not for being sued by my supposedly-trusted life partner.

I haven't had many girlfriends either, but I haven't felt that as a "lack". I've never had many friends either - usually not more than three or four good friends at any time.

I now live alone, and I don't see many people. I talk to my exes fairly regularly, and I'm on good terms with my kids - but they live faraway. I'm not "lonely", though, in the sense that being alone makes me sad or regretful. I'm fine with my own company. I like to crack jokes and talk politics, so I miss those occasions; I miss cuddling a warm woman; and I'd like to have someone living with me, to pick me up if I fall over, and to look after me if I get ill. But those things are basically transactional, not about loneliness; I could pay someone to provide those services.

I'm not a "loner" - I like people, and people like me. I'm not shy. I think it's just that I find that cultivating casual friendships in the hope they might blossom is a lot of work, so I don't cultivate many. And the idea of having two girlfriend relationships at the same time - i.e. while one is ending and the other beginning - fills me with dread, and I've never done that.

Like you, I've spent my career in IT. I've never made a good friend at work. I mean, I've made "friends" with people at work, and even brought them to my home and made dinner for them; but they were never good friends. I'm a bit idiosyncratic in my tastes, and many of my attitudes and opinions are quite leftfield. These work-friends were all very straight, by my standards. I've no objection to people being "normal" - by definition, the majority of people are - that's no obstacle to being friends, for me. But it may have been an obstacle for them.

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by bradlys on Saturday May 21, 2022 @12:49PM (#31459482)
It really doesn’t say much about you that you got divorced. Women initiate ~70% of divorces and 90% for college educated women. Personally - I don’t know any college educated couples who had the man initiate. It’s really uncommon.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @12:18PM (#31459189)
It's very interesting what you say, how you miss certain aspects of companionship. Do you find the maintenance of friendships and of intimate relationships difficult in the same way? Personally I find almost no overlap between the two categories.

I've actually found most of my most intense friendships via computers - though those are few, and to be honest I've mellowed in my middle age. I'm trying my hand at making friends through social activities more these days - I definitely enjoy conversing, and sharing a laugh with them.

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by denton-scratch on Saturday May 21, 2022 @01:51PM (#31460156)
> Do you find the maintenance of friendships and of intimate relationships difficult in the same way?

I don't find it difficult to maintain an intimate relationship, until the writ arrives! I can compromise, I can listen (up to a point - I am a man, after all), and I'm pretty tolerant.

In both friendships and intimate relationships, I expect two-way trust. The difference is that in an intimate relationship, I'm relying on that trust; I don't place the same reliance on a good friend. I think it would be unkind (and unfriendly) to lean that heavily on a friend.

I lost my closest and oldest friend when he stole something from me (it actually was my partner's, which made it much worse, because she had relied on my trust in him). But in general, I wouldn't be that put-out if a good friend broke trust; people have lives to live, they make commitments to new people, and they make new friends that might take a dislike to you. These things happen, but I don't expect them to happen in a committed relationship.

But they do happen; so clearly my expectations are still out of whack with reality.

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by simonswords82 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @03:37AM (#31456032)
Hi fellow UK person.

Sounds like you're just about to make a relatively large (perhaps dramatic?) change to your home and work life. Some people would call that a mid-life crisis but I think it's people realising the shortness of life and making sure they don't waste whatever they have left of it.

Hope whatever the outcome it's a net positive :)

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:13AM (#31457182)
Hey fellow UK person!

I may be on the brink, as you say, about to jump - or I may just be all talk. I'm not sure myself, if I'm honest :-) Though I am sure that I definitely prefer solitude + a number of friends now and again, rather than one super intense soul-mate all the time.

Thanks for the good wishes, and best of luck to you too!

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by JKCalhoun on Saturday May 21, 2022 @10:24AM (#31458189)
If you can, I wonder if tried a period of separation, maybe 6 months? To test the waters. My gut instinct is you may find divorce is not what you wanted after all, just some time and space to realize that.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by ta44445 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @07:28AM (#31456964)
This resonates a bit with me. I'm at an earlier point in life (25 now), so I realize giving advice may be naïve, but I feel inclined to share my experience so far still.

I share the part of your story about liking computers and getting a wonderful career out of it - I currently work remotely in a low cost of living country making six USD figures, so I'm quite well into the 1% income bracket locally. Up until maybe a year or so ago, I'd been in 3 relationships, all multi-year, including a long distance one during university. It always felt that I had been missing out on the "single guy" part of life, and looking back now, my relationships weren't all that fulfilling; mostly they were probably a way to not be alone, although I still felt alone, and was ok with that.

This past ~year I've been out casually with many women (maybe something like 15?) and... It's fun, but obviously it's not fulfilling other than for ego reasons. I think the main positive thing in it is that I know it's "just ok" and don't have to wonder about it; if I had committed early on this would likely be something that would always be on my mind. What if I was letting my best life go by? Well, I haven't found ultimate happiness, but I have found comfort in the fact that I looked for it at least, and won't regret not having done so.

For me, casual relationships aren't really fulfilling, and committed ones aren't either. I've learned to be alone and even a bit alien from early on, and don't resent it.

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by jjfoooo6 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:27AM (#31458723)
I'm a bit older (35) and what I've come to view about my earlier relationships is that I didn't invest much in them. Didn't share my feelings, didn't make myself vulnerable. At the time I thought I just wasn't meeting the right person, now I feel there were probably a dozen women I went out with that could have been terrific partners.

This is not to criticize embracing being single at 25. It's a good opportunity to figure out who you are and what you like. But the empty "a way to not be alone" relationships also happens in short term relationships and casual dating. You get what you put in.

> I haven't found ultimate happiness

You will not find this, it does not exist, and it is certainly not obtained by catching some mythical "the one." Unreasonable expectations will doom any relationship.

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by xtiansimon on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:39AM (#31457340)
Im 51 and still single. I’d only offer that the biological clock is real concern for women, and largely drives many realities and possibilities of their decision making process. If you’re dating and unsatisfied, maybe consider a journey of deep thoughts about having a family. Seek mentors or therapy if that’s what works for you. Then _maybe_ you and the women you are dating will grow closer with shared experience and renewed sense of the human condition.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:21AM (#31457239)
BTW, I 100% sympathise with being alone and alien. Alien is an apt description, actually. I came to love the delicious distance, and feeling of otherness. It was a slightly depressive feeling, but very comforting. Not many people can appreciate that, I've found.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by starkd on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:17AM (#31458621)
It also helps to know you don't have to be "joined at the hip" to your partner all the time.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @08:06AM (#31457158)
Not at all naive, anyone might have a piece of the puzzle, no matter what their age is. It sounds to me like you've done a better job than I did, exploring relationships with women, and figuring out what works for you, so hats off! Tbh I wish I had've had access to the sort of information that's available online now, even just as a window into the breadth of people's views - they can redefine what is a "viable" viewpoint or lifestyle, and help a person find their way to a life that makes them happy.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by dazc on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:03AM (#31458500)
Be careful about what you are considering throwing away. I'm a bit older and when people ask me why I'm not married I reply simply that all the best women were snapped up in their 20's.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by starkd on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:09AM (#31458551)
I once heard someone put it, as to why he wasn't married, that he wants what he can't have, and he can have what he doesn't want.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by te on Saturday May 21, 2022 @05:05AM (#31456400)
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by jjfoooo6 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:10AM (#31458562)
> I would like to start living life as I would like it, both career and relationship wise

If you'd be comfortable sharing, why do you feel this is not something you can achieve with your partner?

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @11:43AM (#31458867)
Sure, I can share - and needless to say, the vast majority of the problem is on my side. My wife is indeed a great woman - very emotionally focussed though, in quite an intense way, and highly intelligent in an intuitive way. She's honest and loyal though, and good looking. A real catch, in other words. The problem that I bring, is that I don't really have a core personality (at least, not one that anyone sees - I have my own inner thoughts but they can be rather dark, and need extensive filtering before being presented to the world at large). So I run "sub programs" to talk to other people on a level that is suitable to get along with them. I think everyone does this to an extent - I certainly do anyway, I always have.

So the problem comes, because my wife is an exceptional empath, with what seems to me like almost supernatural intuition. And she sees through my little constructs in a second, and demands they be pushed aside, in order to get to know the "real me" beneath. Trouble is there is no "real me", apart from the rather dark, turbulent thoughts that churn the waters of my inner life. Therein lies the problem, a perpetual game of hide and seek, and I find it rather wearing. (Largely my own problem though, as I said).

Apologies if the above sounds a bit weird, or off-putting or whatever. Anyway - you did ask! :-)

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by jjfoooo6 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @12:41PM (#31459397)
I'm 35, am in therapy, just got out of a breakup, and have two good friends with a dads who divorced their moms at around your age. Since you've been receptive to my other comments I'll share a bit about how your comment strikes me.

> I have my own inner thoughts but they can be rather dark, and need extensive filtering before being presented to the world at large

This really sounds like a good thing to reality check with a therapist! Non-judgmental listening is a core piece of the service they provide.

I've had similar feelings in the past. Having things you don't feel you can share will make you feel isolated. Saying these things out loud to someone in and of itself can be a load off. And I strongly suspect these things you're suppressing aren't as bad as you think.

It's telling that your response has nothing bad to say about your wife. The issues you raised are really, really not going to be solved by leaving her.

When I'm unhappy in a relationship being single feels like freedom. But a breakup is trauma. During mine I went through hell, my entire being was be screaming at me that I'd made the worst mistake of my life. The loneliness was profound. Self esteem plummeted. My ex-girlfriend went through hell too.

As it happens, my breakup needed to happen - I want a family, my ex-gf could not commit to having one with me. I'm on the other side now and feel good about the decision. But I still miss her all the time. And this was a relationship of only a few years.

Lastly, on my friends with dads who have divorced their mom in his 50's - this decision will permanently change your relationship with your children. One doesn't talk to his dad at all, the other tolerates but no longer respects his dad. Are those scenarios possible?

Good luck. Maybe it is that you have to leave your wife. But do your due diligence that this is the case. It's a button you can't unpress.

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @02:43PM (#31460611)
I think you're right - I will talk to someone before doing anything drastic.

I've taken more than enough of people's time today (thank you and others for your insights - they are really useful). I did want to clarify something about my thoughts though - it's not that they're always dark and horrible at all - but they are rather opaque to an outsider. As I mentioned, I grew up alone for large swathes of time, and I learned to have conversations with myself, as a form of companionship. Such conversations form my inner life - but its difficult to let someone else in on them. As an example, here's Bill Burr with a story about muffins, which I relate to so much - it still makes me cry with laughter even though I've watched it about 1000 times. :-)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnOg01N1u3w

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by jjfoooo6 on Saturday May 21, 2022 @04:44PM (#31461606)
There's nothing anyone appreciates more than a listening ear to unsolicited advice on the internet :)

Thanks for the clip, Bill Burr is hilarious

Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by seunosewa on Saturday May 21, 2022 @12:42PM (#31459403)
Let her in anyway. She might not leave, but if she does, you'll know that you gave yourself a chance to be your true 'dark' self with her. Your dark self may be treatable, even.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by taylorius on Saturday May 21, 2022 @02:18PM (#31460396)
I don't know that I want to treat it - it's the core of me after all, and I've only ever felt "broken" in a marriage situation. And it's not like my thoughts are always dark anyway, it varies. It's more like a conversation between two people, with 100% trust, and where nothing is off limits - but it all takes place in my head. So it's difficult to share, because it's self contained and dynamic. As I mentioned, I grew up entirely by myself for much of the time, and I suppose my internal conversations grew to become my primary source of entertainment. It's hard to just "fix" that, it's who I am.
Re:On Aging Alone (2021) by everybodyknows on Sunday May 22, 2022 @10:50AM (#31468802)
Given thoughts that are socially unacceptable in conversation, consider working them out at one step removed, as the thoughts of some fictional character in an invented story. Perhaps in the form of a novel, or stage play or film script.