Re:Formula for a Shortage
by mrguyorama on Friday May 20, 2022 @02:38PM
(#31451015)
Specifically they should look at the many times baby formula has been adulterated with literal poison and the horrors that nestle commits and then ask themselves if they really don't want some sort of safety.
Remember, this shortage is because a brand was selling dangerous formula and had to take it off store shelves
How about we bust up any company holding more than 20% of the market share for baby formula? And then we bust up any company holding 20% of the inputs for that? Recurse until finished.
Then, when one company gets contaminated, we only lose a maximum of 20% of the market.
Maximally efficient is minimally robust.
Exactly. It's a reasoning error.
They equate "Ensuring any recalled products remains off market" with "keeping formula off the market".
As you said, there are many cases in which it is far wiser stop to ensure safety, than to move forward with risk.
Well said.
The shortage is certainly a terrible thing. It also would be a terrible thing if contaminated formula killed a bunch of babies. It may be that we have not struck the right policy balance between a free market and regulatory controls, but this screed is far from a nuanced reconsideration of the role of the FDA.
[0]: https://www.fda.gov/files/about%20fda/published/The-Sulfanil...