News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by DoreenMichele on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:21AM (#31406319)
Good.

European women generally sought help with carrying the burden of child bearing and child rearing and gains in terms of employment followed. American women generally took the very American position of "Don't tread on me!" and it hasn't been as effective.

There are better ways to address such issues.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by Loic on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:33AM (#31406392)
In Germany and France, the women are fighting to get such laws going through.

My very personal take on the issue is that one needs such law to "change the habits" and then hope that the new normality later reduces the need for such laws.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by tgv on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:46AM (#31406822)
I see it as window dressing at best. Getting a job on a board is great for that one person (they get money, influence, status), but doesn't do anything for the others. I've asked this before: what's the goal, and how does putting women (in this case) on boards help towards that goal?
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by TuringTest on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @03:20AM (#31407051)
> I've asked this before: what's the goal, and how does putting women (in this case) on boards help towards that goal?

It's all about overcoming inertia by pushing against it. There's a cultural bias in corporate boards to only or primarily hire men. Putting women on them can show that they are equally capable, and gives these women the opportunity to create the contacts needed so that other women in the future will also have access to them. All this is more difficult as long as the cultural tendency to discriminate in favor of men remains unchanged.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by flipbrad on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:20AM (#31407448)
I suspect these laws bear out their effects in considerably more numerous (and more subtle) ways than many critics realise. I suspect most will understand (i) the law immediately addresses a numerical imbalance, and (ii) also creates visible models/ examples to inspire future women to go for board seats. But also (iii) it builds the CVs of the current crop of women benefiting from the law to get onto boards, meaning they'll be less at a disadvantage next time they apply for another board (people are often on multiple boards at once), boosting 'organic'/'natural' (non-discriminatory) gender balance in the competition for seats; and (iv) when it comes to replacing the female board member, the company/organisation can more naturally contemplate another woman also doing a great job in that seat (whether or not they hire one into that seat would be a question of available candidates, but at least the headhunters and board would be able to - at least - imagine a woman in the role). Those are all quite significant levers.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by tgv on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:59AM (#31408182)
> Putting women on them can show that they are equally capable

How is that a goal? Putting someone on a board isn't visible, at all. Almost nobody sees board members, and certainly nobody sees their achievements (which is needed to demonstrate capability). And visibility/perception of capability hasn't been needed in the past. Women have stormed institutions that were male bastions once.

> so that other women in the future will also have access to them

That's circular reasoning.

Note that I'm not at all arguing against anyone in a board position. It's just that this seems to be a "feel-good" measure without any reason and effect.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by TuringTest on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @09:46AM (#31410531)
> Almost nobody sees board members, and certainly nobody sees their achievements (which is needed to demonstrate capability). And visibility/perception of capability hasn't been needed in the past. Women have stormed institutions that were male bastions once.

Won't other board members see their achievements, and aren't board members responsible for choosing new members? Having women there should work to make their peers realize that being a woman is not by itself a handicap for the position (contrarily to the tradition of irrational beliefs that it does).

> That's circular reasoning.

No, it's compound interest. Getting the ball rolling is important so that the process will increase speed by building on the previous efforts, until reaching the point where the artificial pressure is no longer needed.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by tgv on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @10:10AM (#31410928)
It's circular if the sole goal of putting women on corporate boards is to put more women on corporate boards. I doubt that's the goal, though.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by TuringTest on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @10:19AM (#31411070)
Obviously. The goal is destroying the mindset that prevents having more women on corporate boards to begin with.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by tgv on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:35PM (#31413925)
Ok. But I don't think that's going to be done by putting them there. Nothing suggests it would. Instead, it's a slow process of endless education. And I'm afraid the people at the very top are (on average) the more conservative, so it's a long, uphill battle. Giving a bunch of women a cushy job isn't going to achieve that goal. Chances of it backfiring are real, too: one foobar and the mindset is back again, rooted firmly in evidence this time.

For comparison: look what a black president has done against racism in the USA. OTOH, I don't believe putting women on a board of directors is going to make companies perform worse. So many seats are taken by mediocre bootlickers. But I still think it's not going to help women in general.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by nicoburns on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @06:28AM (#31408403)
The idea is that membership of boards is often chosen by existing members of said boards, and that people (not always, but on average) have a tendency to choose people who are like themselves. And boards are typically male-dominated due to historical sexism, so the goal is to disrupt that inertia with an external push towards a more diverse group, with the hope that it will then be self-sustaining going forwards. And this is considered desirable because it means that opportunity and power is more evenly distributed across different sections of society.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by belorn on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:57AM (#31406891)
If such law is effective and useful then we should use it in a gender neutral way in all places where gender segregation exist. A good verification that a law is good is when the usefulness of the law remain the same regardless of whom it is targeted against or whom favors by it.

Few laws got removed faster then when one such law was tried in Sweden, and the argument was the exact same thing as in California. No one likes discrimination, and when the "wrong" demographic benefited the political support goes into negative. Sweden has a worse gender segregation than US, and at the extreme end you got profession and educational programs that are practically single-sex. Gender quotas would force a change of habits, but you won't find much political support for it. Would even you be a supporter if it was used as a general tool against gender segregation?

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by DoreenMichele on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:48AM (#31406461)
Well, I am skeptical that such an approach is really a good idea. So I personally hope they aren't throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by epgui on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:54AM (#31406488)
Are you skeptical of whether the approach is morally good, or of whether it's effective? Because it is often very effective over time.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by DoreenMichele on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @01:57AM (#31406508)
My concern would be that it could lead to women getting positions for which they aren't really qualified and this undermining corporate health over time, among other things.

Having a smaller slice of a larger pie can be a better deal than a larger slice of a dying economy because people are being stupid in the name of ethics and equality.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by epgui on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:04AM (#31406557)
That is more of a short-term concern: over the longer term, it is widely understood that establishing more equitable opportunities has the effect of redressing systematic inequities that are preventing full participation & competition of traditionally marginalized groups.

The classic illustration is that the increased prevalence of women/black/hispanic/indigenous role models in STEM, for example, encourages a higher degree of participation and competition from these traditionally marginalized groups in the field.

If there is no good reason to think these marginalized groups are inherently less suited for the role, then over time, they should be selected on the basis of merit in roughly demographic proportion.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by DoreenMichele on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:08AM (#31406585)
Historically, "men" were made, not born. You had to prove yourself a man. You weren't granted that status based solely on the bits between your legs.

Women who join male dominated groups tend to feel the men are just being mean to them because male and female culture differs.

It's probably a waste of my time to try to discuss it here.

So I think I shall bow out without completing my thought in this comment.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by epgui on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:10AM (#31406602)
> Historically, "men" were made, not born. You had to prove yourself a man.

I don't think women had the historical opportunity to be "made a man", so this very-rhetorical argument / play on words is not particularly persuasive.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by krageon on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @05:52AM (#31408132)
You see such stories in media (and I would wager in practice, with any lady that enters a male-dominated group and ends up actually fitting in) frequently enough.
Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by didibus on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @03:20AM (#31407052)
Boards of directors of public companies are normally elected by shareholders. I wouldn't say they're chosen based on their real qualifications, more so their reputation and popularity.

The number of seats is kind of arbitrary from what I understand, you could add more or have less seats.

Also what the board is responsible for is generally governed by government regulation in some jurisdiction.

The whole thing is about corporate oversight to some extent, supposed to be you have unbiased members that don't have skin in the game like execs and CEOs and other employees and who can represent shareholder's interests as well as government regulation.

I'm not sure how I personally feel about the law, but the idea that you'd need say a gender parity of board members isn't that insane as compared to say for hiring for a doctor, engineer, scientist, etc. If you think of the purpose of the board to be that unbiased oversight, you could argue diversity is a good way to optimize for reduced bias.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by DoreenMichele on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @03:24AM (#31407077)
the idea that you'd need say a gender parity of board members isn't that insane

I'd like to shoot for a higher standard than "less nutty than some other proposal" personally.

But I'm weird that way.

Re:Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional by Loic on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @02:12AM (#31406613)
Do not worry. Women are totally qualified to get such positions. In fact, in Germany/France, they are usually more qualified than men. I don't know in the US, but on my side of the Atlantic women must be 10 times better than men to be considered for the same responsibility job.

For me as an external consultant for big companies, it means I really enjoy working with women. They are always extremely good in what they are doing as soon as they are one level up.