Re:The ‘flawed five’ engineering productivity metrics
by dilyevsky on Monday May 16, 2022 @03:16PM
(#31402024)
So you’re becoming “aware of what each other is doing” by half reading the pr title and going straight to approve button? I think “legitimately “ is doing a lot of lifting here too
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The ‘flawed five’ engineering productivity metrics
by yodon on Monday May 16, 2022 @03:49PM
(#31402374)
You seem to presuppose that the people involved in the team conversations about these metrics are stupid or clueless to a point of willfulness or intentionally bad actors. If that's the case, as with the case where you're somehow able to approve your own CR's, you face problems unrelated to the numbers. If those are the kind of problems you face, you need to fix them well before you try to bring in any processes designed to help a well functioning organization function better, including the case you called out where devs are approving code reviews without understanding them.
Re:The ‘flawed five’ engineering productivity metrics
by a1369209993 on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:25PM
(#31404974)
Actually, they seem to be presupposing that you're using these metrics as a target to judge employee performance by (in the style of key productivity indicators), rather than as a diagnosic tool to debug your/management's own mistakes/potential improvements in how the team is organized, and then pointing out in what way the former approach - which always fails regardless of which metrics you use due to Goodhart's law - fails with this particular choice of metrics.
Edit: granted, sometimes the result of said debugging is that it really is a hardware problem, and with how unstandardized people are, that's actually common enough that you'll likely run into it. But you don't fix (for example) a disk drive that reports writes as complete before they're peristed by stack-ranking drives and trying to pick the ones that lose data less; you fix it either by replacing the faulty drive immediately (assuming you can get working drives), or (more relevantly to dealing with people) by working around it in software.
Re:The ‘flawed five’ engineering productivity metrics
by dilyevsky on Monday May 16, 2022 @06:09PM
(#31403723)
Never said anything about approving your own prs nor bad actors. It’s just basic human psychology especially when money is involved and if you’re going to pretend it does not exist you got another thing coming