News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:17PM (#31400510)
>There is no possible way that trillions of new bitcoins could suddenly be created.

That's a slightly strong perspective; it is not impossible; it is merely extremely hard.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:29PM (#31400697)
> it is merely extremely hard.

Care to elaborate how it could be done?

Even if it were to happen, which it could not, the chain would fork from the moment before the hack and continue on without the hack.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @01:44PM (#31400914)
Change to Bitcoin Core; hard fork; majority of miners and nodes move to new fork.

The only reason we're not calling "Bitcoin Cash" by the name "Bitcoin" is that the last part didn't happen, right?

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:38PM (#31401595)
Consensus. Why would the majority people adopt broken bitcoin?
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by NovemberWhiskey on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:44PM (#31401673)
You asserted it was impossible; it isn't. It's merely, as I said, extremely hard.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by anothernewdude on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:40PM (#31403470)
Bitcoin already faces this problem.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by sha255 on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:28PM (#31401469)
It’s interesting how cryptocurrency advocacy makes otherwise intelligent people discard all principles of engineering with forceful statements like “it’s impossible,” when the only thing realistically standing between someone and as much Bitcoin as they want is SHA-2 compromise. I’m amazed with the money in play that it hasn’t happened yet. It speaks to the strength of the SHA-2 suite (and, complicatedly for me, the NSA) that it’s survived this well with a giant target on its back thanks to cryptocurrency.

Even here, you’ve assumed such an event would be a hack. Sure, one is not going to introduce trillions of coins, but a fast way to design a desired SHA-2 solution is a lot of cryptocurrencies’ factorization heel and played correctly could slowly make one incredibly wealthy (played poorly, it’d just collapse the entire currency and probably the whole idea).

You know how we’re all terrified of fast factorization and its implications for cryptography? Do you really think with the basically five minutes of research the industry has into quantum computing that SHA-2 is good enough for the entire life of a currency? We’ve already shown that coins can’t fork to change stupid shit, so I mean, good luck with an owned hash. So, hard, not impossible. Just don’t forget: once upon a time we thought MD5 was awesome and you’ve never heard of MD4.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by eric_cc on Monday May 16, 2022 @02:41PM (#31401632)
“It’s impossible” - I agree it’s almost always too strong.

However, remember we’re discussing the creation of trillions of bitcoin. Even if it occurred, do you really believe the chain would remain? It would be forked. I just can’t imagine a chain being totally compromised and its users being okay with it - both would need to be true.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by solveit on Monday May 16, 2022 @03:23PM (#31402117)
A smart attacker wouldn't create trillions of bitcoin, they would create a steady trickle of bitcoin indistinguishable from a medium-sized private mining operation that is too small to be noticed for a good while but large enough to make the attacker very very rich. It won't be noticed for months or even years and you cannot erase years of history. There will be no fix, only damage control.

That said, SHA-2 being broken is not very high up on my list of cryptocurrency failure modes if only because there are much more immediate concerns... and I suspect most other people implicitly feel the same way.

Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by deadbunny on Monday May 16, 2022 @05:14PM (#31403209)
That not how bitcoins are created. You don't just make a few extra. The block reward is fixed, if someone made a block with more than the block award it'd be rejected by the network.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by thematrixturtle on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:32PM (#31404296)
No need to create net new coins, if you can crack SHA you can start moving around somebody else's existing bitcoins. Choose your target carefully (lots of dormant and/or hacked BTC out there) and nobody will twig on for a long, long time.
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by derangedHorse on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @10:44AM (#31411452)
The transference of Bitcoin still relies on digital signatures so the only way to forge transfers would be if ECC (or bitcoin’s implementation of ECC) was broken).
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by solveit on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @03:17PM (#31415174)
You are agreeing with me. An attacker that has broken sha-2 would pretend to be a miner, not mint trillions of bitcoin (which is not possible as you say).
Re:$3B in Bitcoin was sold in a last-ditch attempt to save U... by Sebb767 on Monday May 16, 2022 @07:55PM (#31404446)
> Care to elaborate how it could be done?

Either someone puts up an enormous amount of computational power to flood the chain or someone finds a fatal flaw in sha256 and uses that to flood the chain. The former is basically impossible, the latter is just very unlikely. Either way, if someone manages that feat, we can consider Bitcoin practically broken.