News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by api on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:29AM (#31396867)
No because it's mostly not P2P. A lot of it is centralized. There are central servers behind things like MetaMask or hosting most NFT content.
Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by web4 on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:37AM (#31396983)
you can point MetaMask to a different RPC endpoint or your own local node. it is like suggesting BitTorrent is centralized tech because many users download torrents on a centralized website.

most NFTs (of value) are using IPFS or Arweave not a URL.

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by kkielhofner on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:07AM (#31397429)
You certainly can point to a local blockchain node but the question is - have you ever run your own?

Running your own blockchain node is nothing like BitTorrent. The required storage, memory, cpu, and IOPS performance is already pushing the limits of readily available standard hardware.

This applies mostly to Ethereum. When you go to higher throughput chains like Solana and Polygon the node requirements jump to hardware that’s unobtainable/impractical for most people - top of the line NVMe drives with storage requirements beyond a single drive (typically need striping for IOPS anyway). Solana all but requires CUDA acceleration. Syncing the Solana devnet constantly uses at least 50% of my RTX 3090…

IPFS is even worse - the CPU, memory, and bandwidth requirements to do anything beyond playing around are ridiculous.

There’s a reason virtually everyone uses various node providers. This is rapidly setting the stage for all real-world uses of blockchain to end up on Web3 AWS (Alchemy, Infura, Piñata, etc).

The entire Arweave network currently hosts about 64 TB of data. In the scope of a worldwide network that’s… Not a lot.

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by po1nt on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:28AM (#31397832)
I believe these issues will solve over time by moore's law. By the time Web3 will be mainstream viable we will all be able to run nodes on our mobile phones.
Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by kkielhofner on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:51AM (#31399223)
Phones have batteries and maintain the decent battery life they have with aggressive sleep, control of background processes, etc.

Ethereum does a tiny number of transactions and I'm not sure Moore's law will keep up with any scale (see Solana and Polygon) as it applies to mobile devices. Then you still have the power and cell connectivity issues.

No one is going to want to wait for their local node on mobile to take a half hour (or more) to sync after it's been disconnected/idle/etc for a few hours/days to make a transaction that should take seconds.

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by web41 on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:58AM (#31398364)
you can run an Ethereum node without running a full node. agree IPFS client is pretty janky but the idea of content addressable p2p hosting is not a bad thing.

the goal of these base systems is not to be faster or easier to use than a centralized Amazon server. the goal is resistance to centralized control.

mod note: my other account “web4” is rate limited after a couple comments?

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by kkielhofner on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:59AM (#31399365)
Yes you can but sync time is still a problem, even today with the minuscule transaction rates supported on most chains. There will likely be advancements there but this is obviously a hard problem as we're already over a decade in with this technology and it has yet to be solved with any kind of approach that can still claim being fully secure and decentralized.

What I'm really trying to point out is that the vast majority of users do not care about centralized control. Even those that claim to pretty quickly realize that platforms with no ability whatsoever to filter content end up with universally objectionable content (such as CASM) and/or content otherwise illegal and/or regularly denounced (revenge porn, extreme violence/murder content, etc).

With centralized platforms today this has shown to merely create platforms that better align with someone's particular worldview while still exercising just as much (if not more) moderation and control.

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by web41 on Monday May 16, 2022 @12:27PM (#31399778)
centralization is not a bad thing - a lot of NFT websites exist that are centralized and curate and moderate the data on the public ledger to give a better UX for users. there can be multiple of these websites that co-exist - like how you can visit different book shops that sell the same product.

the core issue of web2 is that users are locking value into walled gardens run by singular corporations. if the corporation changes like Elon buying Twitter, the users have no power to escape. the same is not true in a web3 app where users can (and probably already are) operate on the shared data across a variety of platforms.

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by Karunamon on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:42AM (#31397033)
IPFS only enables decentralization, it doesn't guarantee it. I'd be willing to bet most NFT content is only pinned by the exchange.
Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by kkielhofner on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:57AM (#31397284)
Most NFT content is hosted with HTTP(s).

Many NFTs that reference an IPFS url point to a specific IPFS gateway run by the creator as opposed to a “standard” IPFS url with ipfs://

I know this because I have a product that indexes various blockchains and the referenced content.

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by Karunamon on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:11AM (#31397476)
Wow, the situation is even more dire than I thought. So by and large, the decentralization benefit is completely off the table for most NFTs.

Would you be willing to share some numbers on what you're seeing? This is valuable information.

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by kkielhofner on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:47AM (#31399157)
We'll be providing these kinds of stats in real time when we launch!
Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by web41 on Monday May 16, 2022 @10:59AM (#31398393)
how many of those are minted with OpenSea? and how many are high value - not spam?

OpenSea engineers should be shamed for their use of HTTPS URLs in contracts, but it is not the norm outside of their minting platform.

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by kkielhofner on Monday May 16, 2022 @11:46AM (#31399150)
Many are minted with OpenSea (of course).

In any case across the 70 million or so NFTs I have indexed HTTP is definitely the majority.

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by web41 on Monday May 16, 2022 @12:30PM (#31399829)
good to know!

it would be worth taking a sample of higher value tokens that are not minted by OpenSea. probably the vast majority of those tokens are spam or bots trying to capitalize on existing web content like DeviantArt database.

better platforms like Manifold, Foundation and Zora are already using IPFS or Arweave

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by web4 on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:54AM (#31397228)
maybe but this is still better than a centralized server URL for something that is designed to be owned by the commons. if the marketplace goes down users can just re-pin the asset. even if the asset has been completely garbage collected, if it is truly valuable (like Punks) probably at least one computer in the world will have the asset on-disk, and can just re-pin it to revive the IPFS url.
Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by trainsarebetter on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:59AM (#31397305)
i think that’s the point.

if effective storage proofs ever become a thing, then the later half (decentralized storage) will be standard

Re:Web3 is expensive P2P by cdiddy2 on Monday May 16, 2022 @09:41AM (#31397027)
You can add your own or any node that is public to metamask in the settings. Infura has had outages a few times before so people know how to do this now.