News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Suggest PG: Put ads on HN and donate revenue by DanBC on Friday October 21, 2011 @06:24AM (#3139189)
> People have to click the ads for revenue to be made.

Is that true? I remember someone saying that ad-blockers were evil because the website got revenue for views, not just clicks, and ad-blockers were killing that revenue.

(http://arstechnica.com/business/news/2010/03/why-ad-blocking...)

>There is an oft-stated misconception that if a user never clicks on ads, then blocking them won't hurt a site financially. This is wrong. Most sites, at least sites the size of ours, are paid on a per view basis. If you have an ad blocker running, and you load 10 pages on the site, you consume resources from us (bandwidth being only one of them), but provide us with no revenue. Because we are a technology site, we have a very large base of ad blockers.

Re:Suggest PG: Put ads on HN and donate revenue by conorgdaly on Friday October 21, 2011 @06:43AM (#3139231)
OK, my initial post was premature, After some googling, sites can get income using the CPM/CPI model(Cost per thousand impressions). I stand corrected.
Re:Suggest PG: Put ads on HN and donate revenue by fakelvis on Friday October 21, 2011 @08:08AM (#3139382)
There's also another way of making money from advertising: flat rate.

While I'm opposed to the idea of ads on HN, if it were to be implemented I can't imagine PG looking at CPI/CPC methods. Rather, I suspect advertising space would be 'rented' on a monthly basis for a much higher fee to technology companies, etc.

But I'll reiterate: I'm against advertising on HN for multiple reasons (poor revenue model for a community like this; there are better alternatives; I don't like them), and I would not be surprised if PG was too (although I've not way of knowing).

Re:Suggest PG: Put ads on HN and donate revenue by conorgdaly on Friday October 21, 2011 @06:53AM (#3139250)
Continuing with that thought though: if the people advertising didn't see some sort of gain(financial or otherwise), they wouldn't be long in pulling the ads from HN. It's great getting eyeballs & all but if that doesn't turn into something more concrete, nobody's gonna pay. Sure, other advertisers would step in but they'd see the same results(minimal\zereo ROI) as previous advertisers, and before long, HN would be regarded as a no go for CPI/CPM ads.