I see no incoherence in denying _new_ leases, since O&G sector is already sitting on many existing leases [1], and in the _long_ term I think we need to drastically reduce the production of oil and gas to lessen the damage of climate change. The moves to deny new leases is in line with those views/meets my expectation of encouraging medium-term supply without a long-term commitment to fossil fuels.
[1]: https://www.americanprogress.org/article/oil-gas-companies-l...
> Bankruptcies in the US ensued
Never happened. What happened is that the US voluntarily shutdown their oil production out of concerns for the environment.
So however this idea of the Russians and Saudis would surely make for a good plan, it's more suited for the plot of a new TV series.
As someone who lives in Texas not too far from the oil patch, this made me double cringe. Folks were put out of work, companies went under. They didn't voluntarily decide to stop feeding their families for the reasons you noted. Where did you get that information??
"Bankruptcy debt across the North America oil and gas industry passed $100bn in 2020 for the first time, reflecting the huge financial impact of the pandemic-triggered market crisis.
In what was “arguably the most devastating year in history” for the sector, 108 companies filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy support, with a combined debt of $102bn, according to an analysis by consultancy Rystad Energy."[0]
[0] https://www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/oil-gas-bankruptcy...
I posit the Saudis and Russians deliberately maintained elevated production levels into the COVID shutdowns in an attempt to handicap US energy production. Bankruptcies in the US ensued. Wells were shut. Supply went offline. Now we're begging them to turn the wells back on, and they're not interested.
Evidence to ponder for the unbelievers.
[0]: In March 2020, Saudis and Russians can't come to an agreement about cutting output into a global shutdown (this was clearly a show)
https://www.csis.org/analysis/oil-price-war
[1]: Trump pushes Saudis to cut production into negative oil, US bankruptcies ensue
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-global-oil-trump-saudi-sp...
[2]: Biden tells Saudis to boost production amid $100 oil
https://www.businessinsider.com/us-officials-ask-saudi-boost...
[3]: At all time high prices, OPEC is still behind its production targets.
https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/opec-oil-output-marc...
The beauty of this strategy is that is creates the continued fear that at some point the Saudis will turn on the tap and oil can go sub $60 again (see futures prices at the long end of the curve), so the US is still wary of investing in oil and gas to deal with the shortage.
Everyone seems to forget the Saudis created an oil crisis in the 70s for political gain once. How we are not talking about this today more actively is beyond me.