News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chainless electric drive system “Free Drive” for bicycles... by jandrese on Friday May 13, 2022 @01:38PM (#31370442)
The selling point might be to finally have an "automatic" bike. Standard derailleurs are basically like having a stick shift on a car. The rider has to be trained on how to use them and they will make errors like leaving the gear setting too high when going on an uphill and then being unable to downshift because they aren't turning the pedals fast enough due to the high gear ratio.

This is literally just get on and start pedaling and the bike figures out the rest. It even makes e-bike controls super easy, since you can just set a speed and start pedaling and it will supply just enough juice to make up the difference.

The obvious downside is that it's going to be less efficient than a chain drive, because nothing beats a chain drive. But if you basically get the benefits of an e-bike for free then the efficiency loss isn't a big deal for the rider.

Re:Chainless electric drive system “Free Drive” for bicycles... by ZeroGravitas on Friday May 13, 2022 @02:04PM (#31370734)
There's at least one existing hub drive ebike that uses this model.

It has a single gear, you can spin the pedals backwards to engage full regen, but the secret is that its usually doing a little regen which it stores and uses to help on hills and when accelerating from a standstill.

Re:Chainless electric drive system “Free Drive” for bicycles... by NowhereMan on Friday May 13, 2022 @04:55PM (#31372446)
I am surprised automatic shifting technology doesn't exist. Wireless electronic shifters are readily available now, in addition to power meters. We have devices to shift and devices to tell us when to shift. All that is needed is to marry the two together.
Re:Chainless electric drive system “Free Drive” for bicycles... by opwieurposiu on Friday May 13, 2022 @06:19PM (#31373115)
It does exist, in the form of a CVT and controller invented by a company called NuVinci. I built a cruiser bike with the manual CVT version years ago. It worked but the hub was very heavy. If you were stopped in high gear and you pushed down on the pedal really hard to start going it would occasionally slip. Once you got going it was pleasant to use but don't expect to win any races.

They must not have sold very many of them because Fallbrook-NuVinci went into chapeter 11 and enviolo bought the tech.

https://enviolo.com/products/

Re:Chainless electric drive system “Free Drive” for bicycles... by sorenbs on Friday May 13, 2022 @06:04PM (#31373011)
The Vanmoof bikes have automatic shifters. I don’t like them because they are unpredictable, and you feel the difference. It’s jarring. The Cowboy is single speed, which works pretty well because of the motor. That’s my preferred configuration. But at high speeds it does feel like I’m at a spinning class, and it sounds like this system could fix that.
Re:Chainless electric drive system “Free Drive” for bicycles... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Friday May 13, 2022 @04:00PM (#31371957)
Lets be real, the selling point of this nonsense is that you can ride your electric motorcycle on a bike path and pretend it is a bike because it has pedals.
Re:Chainless electric drive system “Free Drive” for bicycles... by jandrese on Friday May 13, 2022 @05:08PM (#31372550)
Personally, I don't get the hate over people using e-bikes on bike trails. While I am still fully pedal powered I have no problem with other people using e-bikes. Especially if the alternative is for that person to drive somewhere in a car.

Maybe in other areas people are doing 60kph on bike trails or something, but that's not what I see around me. They seem to top out around 20kph or so, which makes them basically just bikes as far as traffic flow is concerned. Sure they will zoom past you on the uphills, but who cares? It's not hurting me or anybody else.

Re:Chainless electric drive system “Free Drive” for bicycles... by Toutouxc on Friday May 13, 2022 @04:36PM (#31372284)
There are lots of overpowered e-bikes with chain + gears, where the power going through the pedals is maybe 5 % of total power, and the rest is electric. This doesn't change or bring anything new to the table.