News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by Graffur on Thursday May 12, 2022 @06:49PM (#31361036)
If they introduce an edit feature people will abuse it in the following ways:

* Bait and switch. Now replies to the original tweet will be out of context

* Everyone will edit their tweet and put EDIT: <Comment addressing all of the replies> at the end. This is what happens on Reddit.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by tomschlick on Thursday May 12, 2022 @07:54PM (#31361524)
The edit button would only be available for say 5 minutes after posting. Would show that it was edited with a history available to see what was changed. And according to Musk, could reset the like / retweets on it.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by ummonk on Thursday May 12, 2022 @10:05PM (#31362431)
What I want from an edit button is just a convenient UI for deleting and resubmitting a tweet with small changes. Right now the UX for that is really bad - if I want to fix a typo I have to copy my tweet text, then reopen the tweet / reply box, paste in the text, edit it, and then re-add any attachments I had included (together with any accessibility text). And doing all this is even more difficult on mobile than on desktop.
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by dave5104 on Thursday May 12, 2022 @07:12PM (#31361212)
> * Bait and switch. Now replies to the original tweet will be out of context

I used to think this could be a problem too... but Reddit has had an edit button as long as I can remember, and bait and switch doesn't really seem to be much of a problem.

Perhaps it'd be more troublesome with the concept of retweets or quote tweets?

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by banana_giraffe on Thursday May 12, 2022 @07:57PM (#31361542)
Maybe it's not a problem, but one of the most upvoted comments is the result of a bait-n-switch:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Music/comments/56cdgm/ama_im_really...

The comment Rick Astley is replying to was originally something like "please swear at me!" ... quite a bit different than what it is now.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by nullc on Thursday May 12, 2022 @07:35PM (#31361375)
> I used to think this could be a problem too... but Reddit has had an edit button as long as I can remember, and bait and switch doesn't really seem to be much of a problem.

Anyone who does it enough to be irritating (instead of funny) will just find themselves banned by subreddit mods or otherwise they're doing it in a subreddit where it doesn't matter and no one will care.

The same community controls don't exist in twitter, so its plausible that it might be more damaging there. But so what? Many of the benefits are clear, the risks speculative. They could mitigate with a history button.

Wikipedia lets arbitrary users edit other users posts and gets by just fine-- not just the encyclopedia pages but the discussion pages too. Part of that is because it has a history so funny business is easily caught, but part of it is that if you give people more way to behaving unambiguously abusively if they intentionally chose to do so, some people will take you up on the offer and you can just remove them from the platform without regret. In that case everyone will be better off than if they didn't have the option to shoot themselves in the foot to begin with.

Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by lupire on Thursday May 12, 2022 @09:19PM (#31362139)
Twitter userbase is far, far dumber than Wikipedia's
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by Graffur on Tuesday May 17, 2022 @04:43PM (#31416064)
Once you see anything controversial on wikipedia you'll see how dumb the editors are there too
Re:Twitter CEO fires two top executives, freezes hiring by joegahona on Thursday May 12, 2022 @07:58PM (#31361547)
More importantly, an edit button will move zero meaningful metrics.