It seems that you might be slightly misinformed about energy. Since the 1950s, there have been a number of advancements in energy production. Some examples are efficient shale oil extraction, tar sands oil extraction, horizontal drilling, deep water drilling, and high Arctic drilling.
As The Futurist discusses in depth[1], annual world oil consumption has been hovering around 32 billion barrels since about 1982. That means oil consumption, at $100/barrel, is $3.2 trillion, or 5% of nominal world GDP.
My take away from that is technology has made the oil supply a non-issue. And, it will continue not being a problem for the foreseeable future. It is not a hard resource limit.
Also, check out the the research going into liquid fluoride thorium fusion. It seems to have potential as a way to do cheap, safe, "easy" nuclear fusion.
Personally, I think that the problem is human willpower and chicken-little attitudes. To increase my technology optimism, I read nextbigfuture.com. Nearly daily, I see an article posted there that makes me go, "Holy crap! We can do that now??!"
[1] http://www.singularity2050.com/2011/07/the-end-of-petrotyran...
The problem is that this technical complexity takes energy. To really understand the "peakist" argument, you have to understand the concept of EROEI: Energy Return On Energy Invested.
Peak oil, for example, is not about running out of oil. There could still be tons of oil around. It's about EROEI reaching near 1:1. When it costs the energy content of a barrel of oil to get a barrel of oil, we are out of oil as an energy source. This could occur after only ~5% of the Earth's hydrocarbons have been extracted.
EROEI for oil has been steadily declining. The first oil drilled was, of course, the easiest to get. Drop a well and it spurts out. Almost all of that is gone outside a few supergiant fields, and those are or will soon be entering decline. Heavy oil, shale oil, and tar sands require a lot of energy to extract and process... far more than "light sweet crude."
All fossil fuels follow the same pattern. Coal and gas have not peaked yet, but they will... almost certainly in the next 50 years. Oil probably peaked in 2005, though it won't be possible to say for sure except ~25 years in retrospect.
I'm also aware of the thorium cycle, etc., but I am skeptical of the ability of such things to scale fast enough. Keep in mind that to maintain growth new energy technologies will have to scale faster than the fossil fuel EROEI decline curve.
I personally do not believe in the "doomer" scenario. However, I do think this: I think the first half of the 21st century will be dominated economically and technologically by the energy transition. The story of this era will be a mad rush to do everything we can to increase efficiency and build out new resources simply to tread water against the fossil fuel decline.
And of course our political class will make it worse by doing the absolute dumbest possible things: subsidizing oil prices to prevent price signals from working, going to war over dwindling oil reserves, interfering in the market for new alternatives, restricting new alternatives, NIMBYism against renewable and nuclear energy, etc.
But, after years of thought, I realized that the EROEI has a fatal flaw. It completely discounts humanity's ability to discover creative efficiency improvements. The EROEI calculations are done with today's technology, and do not include future improvements.
For example, I grew up in Western Pennsylvania, where the oil industry started back in the 1800s. Capped oil wells abounded in the woods, because at some point in the past, it stopped being efficient to drill them with 1800s drilling technology. Today, old high school friends are making bank reopening those wells and even drilling new ones with modern techniques.
The political problem is an interesting one, and I have opinions on it. But I hesitate to air them here because they are unconventional. The haters would probably drop my karma back down to -20.
Keep in mind that EROEI includes not only the energy cost of operating technology but also the energy cost of developing it. Every engineer who worked on that fracking technology? Every car trip they made to/from the office, etc., all has to be included in the energy investment required to get that shale gas out of the ground.
What if in 5-10 years those engineers ride to work in self-driving robo-cars that are all electric, using cheap and powerful graphene-based super capacitors as batteries. They will have time during the commute to daydream about "wild" ways to make the fraking technology itself more efficient. And the all electric robo-cars are charged up from a cheap, efficient liquid fluoride-thorium reactor generator station. Or maybe the they are just daydreaming about an upcoming vacation to outer space while riding in luxury two-stage zepplins[1]. Oh, and the engineer is healthy and performing at peak mental and physical performance nearly continuously because he/she eats a ketogenic diet[2] centered around high-latitude reindeer herding products[3].
There are a lot of ways the world can be better.
[1]http://www.jpaerospace.com/
The data says that Jevon's paradox is wrong. See the energy usage chart here: http://www.singularity2050.com/2011/07/the-end-of-petrotyran...
Since about 1982, the annual world oil consumption has held at roughly 32 billion barrels despite efficiency improvements in petrol energy usage.
Our technological efficiency improvements are doing more with the same amount of energy and not more with more energy, as Jevon's paradox predicts.
Think about this simplified example. Our cars get better mpg today. Which means that we have energy left over to use to sink those 2 mile long pipes into the ocean. Because of the efficiency improvements, we have just done more with the same amount of energy.
The example is not compelling; 100 years ago there were no cars - are we using more or less energy now with the advent of 'car technology'? The obvious answer is: way more. We are not just taking the net energy of 1910 and 'redistributing' it. Because this is what technologies do, provide an advantage that nature does not. But technology is not free - to develop it, make it, use it, dispose of it, all requires a lot of energy. An insatiable thirst to develop and use thingamajigs is what is causing the problem, not solving it.
It's worth noting, however, that we'll never completely run out of energy, so long as Sol keeps burning. Can we sustain anything remotely resembling civilization based only on solar energy and its indirect organic by-products? Well, that's obviously debatable.
> Even if the energy problem is technically solvable, it seems to me that our political systems may be set up to do the absolute worst possible thing
Never doubt the self-interest of the powerful. Some may be short-sighted enough to eat their seed and burn resources in resource wars, but I think we're more likely to devolve into feudalism, where the masses eke out their existence serving the needs of those who control the remaining resources. On the other hand, if any kind of information infrastructure remains when the oil runs out, we also have the possibility of new emergent, de-centralized social structures constructed out of necessity. (Imagine, for instance, a mesh network of hand-crank-powered cell phones which virally alert clusters of villages to band together to defend against marauders.)
Either way, I can't help but feel that our lifetimes are the perfect fulfillment of the old Chinese curse: "May you live in interesting times."
These areas are inherently dirty and dangerous. It's always easy to do Monday morning quarterbacking, but little recognition of the fact that infrequent domestic oil spills may be preferable to endless foreign oil wars.
Resource extraction in general is demonized by the EPA just as much as the pharmaceutical industry is by the FDA. It is hard to regulate an industry which is respected by the public, because they will get some benefit of the doubt. But if they can be turned into polluters and poisoners, it is easy to justify ever greater state power over the sector.
Computers and the internet are in the exact opposite space: highly respected and almost entirely unregulated. So it's hard for many here to see what the fedguv means (they make App Store approval look like a walk in the park).
But once you're on the insides of those sectors, you start to realize that what is holding back oil in the West (and nuclear power, and drugs, and all non CS sectors) are human factors, not physical ones. That is simultaneous harder and easier to deal with than a genuine scarcity of energy.
And that comment about the Deepwater Horizon not being able to drill closer to the shore... that's eyepopping. The shallow-water GoM in the Mississippi Delta has been drilled for decades.
I don't want to use an inappropriate tone for HN, but you should really take stock of how you've been misinformed so badly and seek to educate yourself.
And that comment about the Deepwater Horizon not being able
to drill closer to the shore... that's eyepopping. The
shallow-water GoM in the Mississippi Delta has been drilled
for decades.
Shallow water drilling has been disincentivized in favor of deep water drilling for several years in part because of tourism and NIMBYism concerns. People do not want to see drills from the shore. This is well known in the sector. You can find articles on the topic before 2010 by using archive search in Google News.http://www.stpns.net/view_article.html?articleId=10841083261...
July 13, 2006
Through financial incentives, the House bill encourages
states to allow offshore drilling. For drilling within 12
miles of their coastlines, the states collect 75% of all
royalties. They get 50% of all royalties for drilling up to
100 miles offshore. Louisiana, whose lawmakers authored the
bill, stands to collect an additional $50 billion over the
next 30 years. South Carolina, with no offshore drilling in
its history, has no idea of the potential payoff. The South
Carolina concern appears to be more turf protection by the
tourism lobby, and that includes Gov. Mark Sanford.
South Carolina's $10 billion tourism industry could be
threatened, according to Sanford, *even though the state
could restrict offshore drilling to a distance more than
100 miles out*. The federal authority is demarcated at 200
miles out, and beyond that is open international waters.
Notice: tourism concerns (and NIMBY issues, not mentioned in this piece) are cited as a reason to move drilling further offshore, in part by giving financial incentives (50% rather than 75% of royalties) for locating drills out of sight. Note also that Louisiana's lawmakers authored the bill. You can dig in more if you wish, but there were a variety of reasons why lawmakers preferred drilling further away from shores. And Republicans were just as culpable:http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,166334,00.htm...
July 3, 2001
"Floridians have spoken loud and clear, and their voices
have been heard by President Bush," Florida Gov. Jeb Bush
said Monday after Interior Secretary Gale Norton announced
the administration would ask Congress to let oil companies
drill on about 1.5 million more acres in the Gulf of
Mexico. That's just a quarter of the roughly 6 million
acres that the Clinton administration first proposed
opening for leasing in 1997 and that the Bush/Cheney energy
plan had earmarked for drilling.
Speaking from his parents' home in Kennebunkport, Gov. Bush
called the scaled-back proposal a victory for "Florida's
fight to protect our coastline" and told Bush the words
he's going to be hearing a lot for the next few years: not
in my back yard. "Any lease sales that do occur in the 181
area" — a patch of energy-rich ground in the derrick-free
eastern part of the gulf — "will occur off the coast of
Alabama, not Florida," he said.
The newly proposed area extends to 100 miles south of
Mobile and gets no closer than about 200 miles west of
Tampa. That's actually OK with the folks in Alabama — they
already have plenty of drilling platforms out there, as
does most of the Gulf coastline stretching west to Texas.
And now it's OK with the folks — the Republicans, anyway —
in Florida, who are worried about their white sandy beaches
and the mammoth tourism industry that grows on them.
The compromise was made (and somehow you don't expect
Norton to be overruled later in the week) to appease the
state GOPers whom Bush offended late last month when he
came to Florida to strike an environmental pose at the
Everglades National Park with a bunch of Democrats.
...
The plan allows Ari Fleischer to say the president's new
plan is "environmentally sensitive and balanced" (although
that's what they said about the old plan). It allows Jeb
Bush, up for a tough re-election in 2002, to imagine that
his brother's winning the presidency was actually a good
thing for him politically.
Operative phrase: "gets no closer than about 200 miles west of Tampa". A series of bills and regulations like this, some of them simply interpretations, led to an overall incentive to locate platforms further and further away from the coasts, in uncharted waters.Now, one can claim that tourism was a legitimate reason for these rules. Perhaps. But one must also concede that regulation was a nontrivial factor in forcing these platforms away from the shore.
I'll just say that I'm well aware of the politics and technical issues in the E&P sector as well as domestic and international energy consumption (across all fuel types), and that you are on the border of being completely uninformed on this issue. Frankly, it's sad. You have an opinion, and have used Google to find articles that validate it... and here I am, having read RigZone for years, participating on Oil Drum, having independently given myself an undergrad+ education in petroleum geology, having invested real money in oil companies and reading dozens if not hundreds of 10-Qs and 10-Ks for domestic small to mid cap producers (whose assets span onshore, offshore, UDW, shale, and bitumen). And nothing I can say will jolt you out of your comfortable mindset where there is abundant petroleum for the taking if only DC would step back and let capitalism run its course.
http://www.npr.org/2011/09/25/140784004/new-boom-reshapes-oi...
"[T]he US could be poised to pass Saudi Arabia and overtake Russia as the world's largest oil producer" - true?
Fracking is still a young-ish technique, and last I knew the recovery rates were less than 5%. I don't think it will get above 10% even with technology improvements. Which is still a boatload of Oil / NG / NGL. It's still just 8 years of global demand at current rates.
'The cost of solar, in the average location in the U.S., will cross the current average retail electricity price of 12 cents per kilowatt hour in around 2020, or 9 years from now. In fact, given that retail electricity prices are currently rising by a few percent per year, prices will probably cross earlier, around 2018 for the country as a whole, and as early as 2015 for the sunniest parts of America.'
If solar is at a 7% annual decline is that not a very rapid advancement?
For the U.S., I see a/the primary crisis that is addressable as being energy. And solving it would, directly and indirectly, re-invigorate our economy and provide an entire sector not just of jobs but of careers / career growth. And education.
That the current Administration didn't jump into this aggressively, has been of enormous disappointment to me.
That would be some leadership. Chart the course (course corrections allowed), and advocate -- including with that bully pulpit -- to make it so.
Given that we don't have such leadership (which would be unusual, admittedly), it will have to be bottom up. I just hope that's enough.
Kardashev Level I (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale)
Dyson fusion engines.
He's not talking about unviable Tokamak designs (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokamak), but something much simpler. Basically use H-bombs (which are the only tried and tested fusion technology) to drive a large internal combustion engine. The energy released by each explosion is stored by using it to lift water back into hydraulic dams.
Kardashev Level II
Dyson rings and shells (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dyson_shell).
Kardashev Level III
"Lather, rinse and repeat" with Dyson shells.
[1] Just as all problems in computer science were solved (in principle) at Xerox PARC in the 70s, all energy problems were solved (in principle) at Los Alamos in the 50s.
>It's true that if you look at most areas of technology they are advancing rapidly. Except energy. Energy has stagnated since the 1950s.
This is demonstrably false. Solar power generation, for example, has been enjoyinging the same kind of Moore's Law exponential price/power over the past 15 years that computer processing power has. This is hardly surprising due to the fact that silicon wafer solar panels often use the same semi-conductor suppliers that computer hardware manufacturers do. Newer thin-film solar panels represent a jump in paradigm that promises even greater price performance.
I could have brought up similar points about the progress of wind-power, bio-fuel, or a number of other fields. Energy has anything but stagnated since the 1950s.
tldr: Stay off the peak oil scaremongering sites. They'll blind you.
isn't this what Allen said in his critique? scientific achievement doesn't just grow exponentially - there are those "jumps in paradigm" that move us forward, but they're relatively rare and unpredictable.
For the past 400 years human energy consumption per person has been growing at a relatively smooth exponential curve, despite changes from wood-burning to coal to whale oil to petroleum. Even a cursory unbiased study on the subject will show that. Interestingly, for nearly the entire time, malthusian doomsday prophets have enjoyed more popularity than more rigorous analysts.
Remember that our brains only need a couple thousand kcals per day.
Energy usage of computers is also decreasing, as in mobile devices. There's also anticipated uptake of ARM processors in server farms, because energy usage is a major cost. The advances include advances in energy usage.
We have many options for sources of power; our current choices are mostly preferences. You're right that energy tech has not advanced at Moore-like rates (nothing but silicon does), but it has matched the accelerating demand for it. When it fails to, we'll see serious research into other power sources. (Cheap energy is a curse.)
It's true that if you look at most areas of technology they are advancing rapidly. Except energy. Energy has stagnated since the 1950s.
I'm on the fence on this issue, but there are many very intelligent and knowledgeable people who are predicting a kind of anti-singularity: in the 21st century, fossil fuel depletion will send us way back, perhaps even de-industrialize most societies.
Is our civilization simply a machine that is transferring the order (low entropy state) in fossil fuels into order within itself (technology and economic complexity), and when those fossil fuels run out will this ordering process cease?
The lack of major breakthroughs in energy in the past 50 years is pretty dramatic. Nuclear looked like an energy panacea once, but it's turned out to be clunky and hard to scale. Solar panels and wind turbines are interesting, but the problem with those is that we basically can't store energy. Energy storage is either super-expensive per kilowatt-hour and not scalable (e.g. Li-Ion batteries) or very inefficient (e.g. water electrolysis to hydrogen).
Without a breakthrough on the order of cheap ultra-capacitors or fusion, I'm afraid we'll be seeing peak everything pretty soon, including technological complexity.
The thing is: all the technologies of the "singularity" are energy consumers. Where are the producers? What is going to power the singularity?
Then there's another area that makes me horribly pessimistic: politics. Most of our societies are degenerating to banana republic levels of corruption. Even if the energy problem is technically solvable, it seems to me that our political systems may be set up to do the absolute worst possible thing in this area: ride the fossil fuel crash into the ground in an orgy of war and despotism.