News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google confirms Android 4.0 ICS is open source by ajross on Thursday October 20, 2011 @11:36AM (#3135323)
The headline is off. The linked announcement by Dan Morril said the source will be released after the devices are. So it should be future tense.

But neither is it closed source: there's been no release at all yet, so if you need a term, use "vaporware".

Re:Google confirms Android 4.0 ICS is open source by Tyrannosaurs on Thursday October 20, 2011 @11:40AM (#3135336)
Given that they've demo-ed it at the launch of a handset and that there are videos of it running I think vaporware is both inaccurate and needlessly harsh.

It's an announcement of a future event. If we're calling this vaporware are you also referring to Windows 8 as vaporware?

Re:Google confirms Android 4.0 ICS is open source by X-Istence on Thursday October 20, 2011 @02:11PM (#3136057)
There were videos of Duke Nukem Forever running before it was released, and until its release it was still considered vaporware.

To me it sounds like an accurate term to use. As for Windows 8, I am happily running the alpha they made available so no, Windows 8 is not vaporware.

Re:Google confirms Android 4.0 ICS is open source by pingswept on Thursday October 20, 2011 @11:45AM (#3135362)
I see your point about vaporware, but I think that term generally refers to software that will likely never ship. I don't think Google will fail to ship 4.0.

Right now, the source exists, and I can't get it. I think it's pretty straightforward to call that closed source.

Re:Google confirms Android 4.0 ICS is open source by zmmmmm on Thursday October 20, 2011 @06:54PM (#3137486)
> I think it's pretty straightforward to call that closed source

Straightforward and pedantic. Even the GPL allows a "reasonable" time for someone to yield the source upon request which as been widely interpreted as up to a month. If the source will be available in a reasonable time period then it's reasonable to call the general project itself an open source one.