Re:Chat control: EU Commission presents mass surveillance pl...
by ryandrake on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @03:43PM
(#31331689)
There's a huge difference between skepticism (expressing some contrary opinion) and misinformation (putting forward lies as facts), although I have to admit the spreaders of misinformation have gotten very good at innocently claiming they're "just asking questions."
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Chat control: EU Commission presents mass surveillance pl...
by tremon on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @06:03AM
(#31337809)
Skepticism is not "expressing some contrary opinion". It is a rationalist discipline, very much rooted in logic. A true skeptic will do one of two things:
- put forward sound arguments why a specific viewpoint or presented fact could be wrong
- reserve judgement altogether
Expressing a contrary opinion is not in the skeptic's playbook, because it would be self-defeating: they would be making the same categorical error as they're arguing against.
Re:Chat control: EU Commission presents mass surveillance pl...
by raxxorraxor on Wednesday May 11, 2022 @06:19AM
(#31337908)
That isn't a viable critique. You have to prepare the right answers and bad faith questions are easy to counter. Or maybe not, but you still have to be able to do that. I have seen much more instances where no answers could be provided when people asked legitimate questions that weren't in bad faith at all.