I really fail to understand the whole confusion about FIDO, the amount of misinformation in the threads here (like in the parent comment) is staggering. It is a fantastic invention for expanding privacy& security. Maybe a lot of people confuse it with "log-in with X"?
This is not true for passkey, which the linked article is about. If you set up passkey on a site on e.g. your Mac, the credentials will be synced through iCloud and you can also use your iPhone or iPad as an authenticator. This raises the questions of the grandparent comment:
1. What if a FAANG company nukes the account that you use for credential syncing?
2. What if a FAANG company has access to your private keys?
In the case of Apple, I think (2) is covered. They use iCloud Keychain, which is already end-to-end encrypted. But I am not sure about other companies (Microsoft, Google), does the standard require end-to-end encryption of key material?
We expect that FIDO authenticator vendors (in particular those of authenticators built into OS platforms) will adapt their authenticator implementations such that a FIDO credential can survive device loss. [...]
Just like password managers do with passwords, the underlying OS platform will “sync” the cryptographic keys that belong to a FIDO credential from device to device. This means that the security and availability of a user’s synced credential depends on the security of the underlying OS platform’s (Google’s, Apple’s, Microsoft’s, etc.) authentication mechanism for their online accounts, and on the security method for reinstating access when all (old) devices were lost.
https://media.fidoalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/Ho...
Is it possible to be otherwise?
Forcing all online logins to comply with the wishes of 3 tech giants is even a worse one.
This has nothing to do with privacy. It's about existing monopolies entrenching their monopolies and keeping competition out.
Similarly I can say that passwords suck because there are (entirely optional) centralized password managers. Passwords are unsafe because you can voluntarily share them! Do not use passwords! /s
Not only this creates single points of failure, it also entrenches the already existing monopolies out there. (not to mention forcing everyone to dox themselves by providing biometrics)