Re:IQ Isn't Set In Stone, Suggests Study That Finds Big Jump...
by eurleif on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @05:58PM
(#3132295)
>Now, there is a flaw in the point that you can train for tests - if you trained in this task, then the task has no diagnostic meaning for you. But if you genuinely start working with more spatial reasoning gear - say you become a mechanic of some sort - you get better at recognising how things fit together spatially.
Has it been tested whether training for the spatial reasoning tasks on an IQ test will make someone better at other spatial reasoning tasks (like being a mechanic)?
Re:IQ Isn't Set In Stone, Suggests Study That Finds Big Jump...
by vacri on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @08:24PM
(#3132793)
There's been lots of testing, refinement, and correlation for each subtest and what real-world aspects they're meant to represent. The test derives from a number of psych tests and concepts which have been well-researched over the years.
I don't know if you could say "would mean you would make a good mechanic" based on that one test because that involves other aspects, not just spatial reasoning, but being a mechanic would mean you (probably) deal with spatial reasoning more often than say a journalist or call-centre worker.
Now, there is a flaw in the point that you can train for tests - if you trained in this task, then the task has no diagnostic meaning for you. But if you genuinely start working with more spatial reasoning gear - say you become a mechanic of some sort - you get better at recognising how things fit together spatially. You have, in effect, trained yourself to be better at spatial reasoning in general, and would do better at the subtest.
But the important thing to note here is that your intelligence has improved in that way - your ability to reason spatially has improved; you are actually able to cognitively do more than you could previously.
Likewise with the (culturally-referenced) verbal tests. Someone might get an IQ test at 20, then 'find books' and become a voracious reader. Tested a couple of years later, their vocabulary and verbal reasoning has been significantly exercised and improved. With an improved vocabulary, you are better able to express or consider more advanced concepts, so again, that aspect of your intelligence has actually improved.