Re:AV1 Video Codec
by ummonk on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:00PM
(#31321006)
Can you really save much space by re-encoding an already encoded video in AV1? Wouldn’t the efficiency improvement be offset by the doubling up of compression artifacts?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I just googled a bit to see how much space could be saved by converting Blu-ray AVC content (1080p non-HDR) to AV1 with subjectively same-ish quality, and from what I gathered one can expect to save 40-50% storage space on average (with a spread of maybe more like 20-80% depending on the video). So it’s substantial, but maybe not substantial enough to run and reencode all your movies, unless moving to a free codec is the important motivation.
That seems like a cq based encode. Try av1an in its target quality mode - I've gotten some movies to a tenth the Blu-ray size with 98 vmafs and with only smudged detail at pixel level scrutiny.
The trick is if your encoder can adapt the quantizer based off a metric to compare the encode quality you can save a ton more space without visual degradation.
Re:AV1 Video Codec
by windowsrookie on Monday May 09, 2022 @07:59PM
(#31321536)
You wouldn't save much going from h.265 -> AV1 but h.264 -> AV1 should be a significant savings.
AV1 is ~30% more efficient than h.265. And h.265 is ~40% more efficient than h.264. The lower the resolution of the video, the less savings you will get.
I personally will wait until more devices support hardware AV1 decoding. I believe only Intel 12th gen, and Nvidia 3000 support AV1 currently. I don't plan on purchasing a new laptop or smartphone for 3-4 years, at that point I may start encoding in AV1.
AMD 6000 series cards also support hardware decoding of AV1.
Re:AV1 Video Codec
by post-factum on Tuesday May 10, 2022 @02:25AM
(#31324088)
Except those based on Navi 24 (6400/6500) IIRC.