News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MVC frameworks aren't dinosaurs but sharks by ravenstine on Monday May 09, 2022 @03:58PM (#31318968)
Since I need to actually get off HN and get something done for a change, I can't reply 100% to everything you wrote here, but I appreciate your critical response.

> TBH having worked on multiple high traffic, large-ish MVC apps and high traffic, large-ish react SPA's, I'm a fan of "the old way" of building apps. [...] Maybe I'm looking at the past with rose colored glasses?

That bias exists in all of us, but I wouldn't guess you're looking back with rose colored glasses.

I'm actually more of a fan of "the old way" than I might be letting on. My work for the last 4.5 years has been almost entirely on SPAs, so I'm part of the problem, but I think I've seen the weakness in it as well.

All in all, I'd like for us all to try and avoid complexity from the get-go. That means starting with sites that are server-rendered and to try and not immediately jump to fancy SPAs and other tools. Maybe not everything must be containerized. Maybe monoliths and relational databases are A-OK for most purposes, and scaling up in response to financial success is something that can be handled when the time comes.

At the same time, if we're going through a sanity adjustment as an industry, let's make sure we reexamine the old assumptions that we ran away from in the first place. Otherwise, it's just a pendulum swing.

My main concern about the new/coming generation of tools is whether we also see a similar brawl we witnessed at the Cambrian era of frontend frameworks. A lot of things that seemed like innovations turned out to be headaches and even universally reviled. I can just picture the blog headlines of the next 5 years: "Why we moved away from Phoneix Liveview"

There are no comments on this comment yet.