News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by jessriedel on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @08:15AM (#3129764)
If there's one piece of framework Wikipedia needs, it's a centralized database for citations. That database should contain every book, article, poem, etc. that's cited in any Wikipedia article, and I should be able to re-cite an entry with a single number or tag...without having to re-enter the name of the darn publisher myself.

How much money would it take to make this happen?

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by Thrymr on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @10:38AM (#3130326)
As the article points out, Wikipedia really needs lots of its information in standard forms. Lots of things are done manually that ought to be able to be automated.

I think the citation one is huge. Even the same article often has a "Notes" (for footnotes) section and a "References" section that is a bibliography unlinked to the text. They often both contain citations in different formats. If this is hard even within an article, how is it going to happen across all of Wikipedia? I hope someone takes it on, though.

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by wpietri on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @01:45PM (#3131197)
Part of the problem here is that Wikipedia has traditionally had way more labor than money. So the notion of spending money to save labor -- common everywhere else -- isn't really the default Wikipedia reflex. That seems to be changing some in the last few years, but between the code and the data there's a lot of inertia there.
Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by Thrymr on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @04:41PM (#3131972)
In this case, what's really needed is high-level labor (organization, and maybe programming), and not low-level labor (typing in the damn references by hand). I guess it's easier to get volunteers to do the latter, and the "high-level" volunteers are mostly editors and wiki-policy wonks, not thinking about appropriate data structures and implementation.

It is striking how little Wikipedia has advanced technically since it started, compared with its enormous growth of content.

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by wpietri on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @06:40PM (#3132453)
I think the enormous growth of content (and usage) is exactly why Wikipedia hasn't advanced much technically. In its early years it was a total shoestring operation, mainly focused on keeping the site up under incredible traffic. Just surviving that is a titanic victory.

However, that victory came at a cost: the software fell way behind. The community picked up the slack, making a fantastic reference site despite the handicaps. But many of the ways they did that (e.g., duplicating references all over the place) make improving the software even harder.

Now that Wikimedia Foundation staffing is starting to catch up, I'm sure some of these things will get better. But it's definitely going to take a while.