News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by jonnathanson on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @07:05AM (#3129574)
The problem with Wikipedia -- one that stems from, and compounds, all of the problems mentioned in this piece -- is that the wilderness has been cleared. The fun, groundbreaking contribution work is done. Much of -- if not most of -- the big, foundational, crystallized knowledge base on the site has been written. All that remains now are small(er) updates to limited subfields, rote listmaking, current events updates (never Wikipedia's strong suit in the first place), and editing. Plenty of editing.

None of those things is inherently fun for most people. Your average internet user -- someone who would have loved contributing a fresh article ten years ago -- probably has little desire to devote an appreciable amount of time to curating and categorizing other people's work. But yet, there's a vocal minority of users who do enjoy such things, and those are the "procedural whackjobs" of which you speak.

Call this the rise of the Editorial Class. Wikipedia is now dominated by a small percentage of editors, who revert new work by contributors, and whose arcane rules, lists, procedures, politics, and supercillious disdain make contributing fresh material more a labor than a labor of love. And, lest we think this is noble work put forth by self-sacrificing custodians of knowledge, let me say that my encounters with such people have rarely left an impression of maturity, or even competence. No, for a lot of them, it's a petty power trip. (To wit: one of my articles -- thoroughly researched and painstakingly written -- was eventually lobbied for deletion, successfully, by a little clique of editors calling itself the "Counter Vandalism Unit." As far as I could tell, this is a group of grown-ass adults playing "24" dress-up on Wikipedia, complete with their own badge-like logo, who sadly wield a decent amount of editorial control over the site).

On the flipside, as you point out, some of this works in Wikipedia's favor. More timely sources of knowledge, like Twitter, Tumblr, Facebook, search engines, etc., can beat out Wikipedia's relatively antiquated categorization systems and contribution mechanics fairly handily. But, by and large, most people contributing "content" or "information" through such channels are not really cognizant that that's what they're doing (witness the big uproar over Facebook's data collection; people are inherently surprised that they've been contributing data to any sort of repository of such). Rarely does someone tweet, or post an FB status update, thinking he's contributing to the grand collection of all human knowledge. So the sum total of all the knowledge-data generated outside of Wikipedia, more current and possibly even more interesting though it may be, is still a lot more flab than muscle. That will change eventually, as data mining and contextualization technologies improve. For the time being, however, the lack of an organizing principle similar to Wikipedia's, outside of Wikipedia, will keep Wikipedia relevant. Not indefinitely, but for quite a few years to come.

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by yread on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @08:14AM (#3129760)
>current events updates (never Wikipedia's strong suit in the first place)

I disagree. Whenever there is something big happening, after a couple of days it gets really difficult to follow just from the news (e.g. the Japanese tsunami, Arabian spring). I always go to Wikipedia and get a reasonably good overview with up to date information. I guess it only works for the really high profile events which interest the editors though...

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by tommorris on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @09:28AM (#3130013)
Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by sethg on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @09:10AM (#3129958)
Given the state of higher-ed funding, this is a pipe dream, but... I wish every first- and second-tier university department could make one graduate student the department’s official Wikipedia liaison, spending twentysomething hours a week adding content within his/her area of expertise and skirmishing with boneheaded editors as necessary.
Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by stdbrouw on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @09:52AM (#3130106)
There are some universities that assign Wikipedia articles as coursework: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:School_and_university...

There is a certain learning curve you have to go through when contributing, however, and one that makes sense and has nothing to do with power-hungry editors. Students, grad students or fresh PhDs especially, can sometimes trick themselves into thinking that their niche area of research is the most important thing in the world, and make the coverage of a small subtopic swell out of proportion, or write about it in a way that makes sense for other grad students but not for a broader public. That's something they can grow out of, but not everybody masters the Wikipedia style of writing from the get-go, not even very smart people.

Hence, the reason why I think these assignments are so great is because established Wikipedians get to learn students something about writing for a different audience, establishing consensus and writing in group, and Wikipedia gets better content in return. That's the ideal anyway.

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by stdbrouw on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @07:32AM (#3129633)
Here's where I think Wikipedia could benefit from a good look at how other social systems handle their editorial and decision making processes — for example, how something as simple as +1/±0/-1 makes resolving tough problems so much easier for open-source project, or just the fact that we bundle problems into issue reports.

Wikipedia, on the other hand, has just one endless thread of discussion comments, and like regular comments on news websites that approach is not conducive to civil, intelligent debate in the least.

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by tommorris on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @09:28AM (#3130016)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Polling_is_not_a_subs...

And there are many structured discussions on Wikipedia that follow set patterns and rules. Take deletion: at Articles for Deletion (the area of the site where deletion is debated), there are a set of common patterns and anti-patterns of arguments that you should use and avoid using, and there is a time period where you can submit comments and something vaguely like quorate required before a decision can be made. At the end of a week, the discussion is wrapped up: it's obvious, it gets kept or deleted, and if not, the admin has to sum up the arguments and accept them in a sort of quasi-judicial manner. It's rather more civilized than YouTube or newspaper comments pages...

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by stdbrouw on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @09:44AM (#3130071)
Good points, cheers. It's messy (at the very least just visually) but there are some standards.

I'll stick to my assertion, though, that more people need to think about this stuff, because the organically grown processes don't always cut it — otherwise, you wouldn't have frustrated rants like those of Zed Shaw (http://sheddingbikes.com/posts/1297662169.html) and Jason Scott (http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/808).

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by tommorris on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @09:57AM (#3130134)
And there are people thinking about this and trying to work on software solutions for it. The Wikimedia Foundation are trying to create a variety of tools for new page patrollers (I used to do it) to aid them in better handling the flow of new articles coming in (it's called the "zoom interface").

Another thing that is being tested is making the automatic templates used to notify people that articles are up for deletion or whatever a lot more friendly. For the last month or so, the Foundation and the community have been working together to A-B test better warning templates.

As for discussion threads, there's LiquidThreads, which has been in development for a while but would provide a threaded discussion system sort of like what Reddit and HN have but for Wikimedia talk pages, but still keeping the flexibility of being able to refactor discussions and move stuff about without an admin. LiquidThreads is in use on English Wikinews and on mediawiki.org, but English Wikipedia doesn't have it because it isn't quite mature enough yet (or something, I haven't kept track).

Finally, there's the big one: the visual editor. That's in development at the moment, hopefully with testing starting by the end of the year. This is going to be an opt-out WYSIWYG-style editor. See http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Visual_editor/software_design for a rough idea how it is being built.

There is lots of consensus that things do need to change and Wikipedia does need to have more technical solutions to the problems that are showing with some of the decade-old organically grown social processes.

Re:Wikipedia is a wild success and an utter failure by bane on Wednesday October 19, 2011 @12:47PM (#3130932)
I have to disagree. There's plenty of brush and other mess to clear -- and quite a few trees to plant as well. But the self proclaimed forest rangers will only allow certain kinds or brush around certain kinds of trees to be cleared all the while the paths are covered with fallen trees and the low spots are full of oxygen depleted water and festering pools of mosquito larvae. Attempts to remedy any of these situations are met with deadly force.