News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan's population falls by record 644,000 to 125.5M in 2021 by toomuchtodo on Saturday May 07, 2022 @11:59AM (#31295664)
What supporting citations would you like? There are 121 million unintended pregnancies globally annually. 2.7 millions children in foster/institutional care. 689 million in poverty and destitution. Rainforests are being clear cut, the planet is well beyond its carbon budget (and Herculean efforts will be required to pull us back from 2C), and there is ample evidence climate change is going to cause famines and heatwaves that will inflict suffering on wide swaths of the global population (with the developing world being hit particularly hard). This is not the fiction that religion is, these are verifiable facts (ourworldindata.org, UN reports).

Isn’t it dangerous to have large numbers of people we’re going to just let die when resources are further constrained? It seems a lot safer to argue for family planning for all but the most capable and emotionally invested parents and let everyone else age out with a decent quality of life to responsibly transition to a lower human run rate. No one is arguing for eugenics, family destruction, or similar distasteful policies.

Re:Japan's population falls by record 644,000 to 125.5M in 2021 by zmgsabst on Saturday May 07, 2022 @12:40PM (#31296166)
> Isn’t it dangerous to have large numbers of people we’re going to just let die when resources are further constrained?

You haven’t shown anything like this — merely asserted it based on unrelated facts.

You cited raw numbers, but eg, portion of humanity in starvation conditions has gone down as population went up, because the increased wealth of nations allowed for feeding more people.

Neither unintended pregnancies nor a fraction of children in foster care seems like something that is solved by having fewer people. In fact, that will get worse (like hunger) as society regresses and we are less wealthy as nations.

> No one is arguing for eugenics, family destruction, or similar distasteful policies.

You are: Planned Parenthood was founded by a noted eugenicist; the policies to support your vision require massive taxes that stress the young and prevent them from breeding even if they otherwise would want to; etc.

You’re just denying your role in that destruction through social policy based on some kind of religious apocalyptic fantasy.