Re:Mercedes-Benz says Level 3 self-driving option ready to roll
by slg on Friday May 06, 2022 @07:55PM
(#31290797)
This real life example is more complicated than the Fight Club version. It includes more variables like the added sales I mentioned and all these variables are unknown. How can you draw conclusions about one variable in a formula in which you don't know the value of any of the variables?
Re:Mercedes-Benz says Level 3 self-driving option ready to roll
by refulgentis on Friday May 06, 2022 @08:11PM
(#31290920)
Not sure what you mean: the movie scene has the same property. It's not about the risk of individual failures of components, it's risk of a payout
Strong indicator I believe my anti-flood machine is good at preventing floods is I'm willing to take on paying for any liabilities you incur from flooding
Re:Mercedes-Benz says Level 3 self-driving option ready to roll
by slg on Friday May 06, 2022 @10:14PM
(#31291596)
You are only thinking about payouts and not the change in sales. Imagine you make $100m selling your anti-flood machines. Maybe your machine fails 10% of the time and a failure costs 2x the unit price. Taking on liability in that situation would bring you down to $80m. Bad deal for you. But what if someone in marketing comes and tells you that market research suggests taking on liability leads to an extra $30m in sales. You come out ahead because the $30m in new revenue exceeds the $26m in new liability. That isn’t confidence in your machine. It is marketing and accounting.
Re:Mercedes-Benz says Level 3 self-driving option ready to roll
by refulgentis on Saturday May 07, 2022 @02:09AM
(#31292511)
Occam's Razor: would only work in the short run, crash data goes to regulators.
The Fight Club scene is about how these two things are integrated: their confidence in safety defines their ability to choose to take on liability.
Yes, its intent in the story is to horrify: there's a lack of humanity, a reliance on a simple function relating those two variables.
However, that doesn't imply the two variables are unrelated, in fact, it implies they are completely correlated.