Re:GitHub will require 2FA by the end of 2023
by codedokode on Thursday May 05, 2022 @05:27PM
(#31278601)
This is bad. This, for example, allows sites to accept only government-approved hardware keys with backdoors and do not accept self-made secure keys.
Re:GitHub will require 2FA by the end of 2023
by TimWolla on Friday May 06, 2022 @03:39AM
(#31282432)
This doesn't make sense. As a website author, why would I visibly restrict the security keys to backdoored government keys, when I can simply give the government an invisible backdoor API or direct database access?
Re:GitHub will require 2FA by the end of 2023
by akerl_ on Thursday May 05, 2022 @06:39PM
(#31279163)
This is intentional, given that “self-made” keys have plenty of ways to be insecure, and the average user cannot tell the difference between a well made key and one that is either accidentally or intentionally defective in ways that affect their security.
FIDO2 is designed to maximize security for the majority of users, and the majority of users are using Yubikeys or other hardware-backed tokens provided by big players in their space.
This attestation is meant to allow the service to verify that you use a "blessed" security key with certain security properties (e.g. only a YubiKey 5 they verified to be secure and not some random $5 key with broken RNG off Amazon).