Re:How rare is a Supreme Court breach? Very rare
by larntz on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:41PM
(#31251141)
> That has nothing to do with a majority of people imposing restrictions on themselves. 59% of people in Mississippi oppose abortion, including the majority of women. There is no need for California or New York to parachute in and tell them otherwise.
You could also argue that if 59% of people in Mississippi oppose abortion there's no need to make it illegal. No one will ever force that 59% to start having abortions.
The 59% could simply _choose_ not to have an abortion.
Re:How rare is a Supreme Court breach? Very rare
by rayiner on Wednesday May 04, 2022 @11:00AM
(#31261425)
By that logic, there’s no need to ban beating your dog because you can simply _choose_ not to beat your dog.
Re:How rare is a Supreme Court breach? Very rare
by hunter2_ on Thursday May 05, 2022 @12:32PM
(#31275462)
We give the benefit of a safe life to dogs because beating them offers no benefit (and I should note that we _do_ allow putting them down when they're causing excessive harm).
The same doesn't hold for aborting a fetus, because that can be key to the mother's wellbeing. Whether the scale tips toward that of the mother or that of the fetus is the debate, and since it's not cut and dry, individual choice makes sense.
Re:How rare is a Supreme Court breach? Very rare
by 5678909787 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:26PM
(#31250962)
They are not imposing restrictions on themselves. Anyone who doesn't want an abortion can just not have an abortion. They are imposing restrictions on other people. Being a majority doesn't give you the right to impose restrictions on the minority. Bodily autonomy is an individual right. I don't care if you vote 99% to 1%, that 1% still have the right to control their own body.
That has nothing to do with a majority of people imposing restrictions on themselves. 59% of people in Mississippi oppose abortion, including the majority of women. There is no need for California or New York to parachute in and tell them otherwise.