News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mojang win right to use the name "Scrolls" for their upco... by masklinn on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @05:08AM (#3124485)
> Not exactly.

Not like your comment is any better. A critical part missing from it is that, soon after Bethesda indicated their displeasure, Mojang offered to drop the trademark application (and to move from just "Scrolls" to a composite title).

Apart from the trademark application (maybe, which they've yet to even remotely misuse or abuse with Minecraft, so I'd be more than willing to give Mojang the benefit of the doubt) the only actions I've seen them taking so far seemed to in good faith and in trying to resolve the matter as painlessly as possible for everybody (and somewhat humorously in the case of the Quake 3 match).

> and put themselves in a position where they could take to court game developers who want to use the word "scrolls" in the title of their games (or already use it)

Trademark law is nowhere near as insane as patent law, "scrolls" has been used numerous times as a sub-part of game titles (so the historical record is strongly against such a case), and the only people who have made those claims were trademark trolls (Tim Langdell) who got away with threatening people generally without needing to go to court.

> During the whole process Mojang successfully managed to spin themselves on social news websites as the victims of a David and Goliath fight when they were in fact the ones who started the Trademark offensive.

Please, how is trademarking the name of your next game a "Trademark Offensive"?

Re:Mojang win right to use the name "Scrolls" for their upco... by rmc on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @06:34AM (#3124673)
which they've yet to even remotely misuse or abuse with Minecraft, so I'd be more than willing to give Mojang the benefit of the doubt

Yes now. But they might be bought out.

Re:Mojang win right to use the name "Scrolls" for their upco... by masklinn on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @07:09AM (#3124740)
Right.

In the event that its 4 (I think it's 4) founders (I assume they're co-owners, Notch could be the only owner, I have no hard info on the subject) decide to sell it (it's a private company so it can't just be taken over, and a buyer would need pretty good reasons to get them to sell, considering the founders are probably essentially set for life already) and that trademark law is as screwed up as patent law (it's not) and that the brand new acquirer has a trademark-troll streak, then it could become a risk.

We are pretty far from ArcticCelt's qualification that Mojang

> started the Trademark offensive

are we not?