Re:I replaced my native iOS app with a cross platform web ap...
by hnaccount_rng on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @02:34AM
(#31245366)
I would bet the last thing is intentional. iOS has a reasonably high level of consistency over all apps. Mostly because it’s hard to customize UI elements. And that’s what at least I like about it most
Re:I replaced my native iOS app with a cross platform web ap...
by brundolf on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @12:42AM
(#31244709)
Yeah. And then there are also varying levels of in-between options: React Native lets you write and share JS code but delegates to native UI components on each separate platform, while I believe Ionic actually offers a set of UI components that are web-based, but are designed to adopt the look and feel of each platform as needed. Each of course comes with its own set of trade-offs
This was still a great case-study though! It’s good to have concrete evidence that the performance side of things isn’t an issue
Re:I replaced my native iOS app with a cross platform web ap...
by jen20 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @05:22AM
(#31246307)
> I always find the UIKit components surprisingly tough to customize.
Good - apps should look and feel like the platform.
Re:I replaced my native iOS app with a cross platform web ap...
by jeroenhd on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @05:49AM
(#31246447)
Not if you're trying to make a playful app design like the author is doing. This design is halfway between a normal application and a game.
I would do silly things like clickable image views to get the style right if buttons don't provide the necessary customisability, were I in the author's position. I don't think anyone would be happy with that.
I'm all for platform consistency, which there is very little of these days, but for every API you restrict someone will find a good reason to work around it and that's where the ugly hacks come in.
Re:I replaced my native iOS app with a cross platform web ap...
by sofixa on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @08:01AM
(#31247264)
Really disagree with this. Apps are rarely unique to a platform, and most users aren't on a single platform. I want Google Maps to look the same on the web regardless if I'm on macOS, Linux or Windows, and on my Android phone.
Re:I replaced my native iOS app with a cross platform web ap...
by jen20 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @08:09AM
(#31247310)
On the web that is fine. As a native app, it should fit in with the platform. On iPhone Google use the Android design language, and it produces apps which simply do not meet expectations.
Funnily enough though (and this might just be my lack of skill in iOS development) I always find the UIKit components surprisingly tough to customize.