Square-Enix sells all of its Western game studios and their games to Embracer

Re:Square-Enix sells all of its Western game studios and the... by inopinatus on Monday May 02, 2022 @07:51PM (#31242619)

The market and real estate systems in FF14 are indicative that Square Enix's creative units either have no idea whatsoever about how economies work, or no interest in making theirs fit for purpose. Their efforts in this direction are easily derided as painfully limited, crude, naive, and dysfunctional, certainly one of the least well designed aspects of the experience. This stands in stark contrast to the thoughtful, detailed design evident in gameplay and world-building exhibited by much of the rest of the game. The supply-chain economies and sophisticated markets found in some other MMOs put it to shame.

The buzzword vomit from their CEO is simply a continuation of this trait.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Square-Enix sells all of its Western game studios and the... by mfost on Monday May 02, 2022 @08:48PM (#31242992)

Except that the other MMO economies are horrible to play in. FFXIV is a lot more fun than say GW2 economy driven game.

Subjective you'd say? Maybe but it does show that maybe they know better about what a game needs than you think.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Square-Enix sells all of its Western game studios and the... by inopinatus on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @06:07AM (#31246528)

Subjective perhaps, but I don’t think the soft soap stands up to scrutiny. Case in point, witness the absolute fiasco of this month’s “property lottery”. A shitshow of bad design, disastrous implementation, and consequently failed rollout, which somehow won’t be resolved for weeks. As for the market; anyone who tries to run a shop is in for a world of pain, forced to micromanage their listings using the clunkiest of tools, in an unstable market with limited price signals and irrational competitors. Fun? No sir. It’s a pain in the ass.

I can’t speak to GW2, but cherry-picking something you clearly think is worse sets a very low bar. I don’t accept that meeting a low standard is a reasonable expectation. A long long time ago I used to help run an Eve:Online corporation, and there the sophisticated economy and market systems made for a vastly richer player experience.

The point being, Square Enix can’t be taken seriously when they talk about in-game economic structures. Their track record is one of incompetence and indifference.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Square-Enix sells all of its Western game studios and the... by hnick on Monday May 02, 2022 @11:32PM (#31244228)

FFXI had a better economy, but it comes down to the fact they don't seem to want money to matter in FFXIV. The game hands it out like free candy but it's only really worthwhile on cosmetics unless you buy into day 1 gear. Couple that with vertical gear progression and nothing is exciting - it's all the same items with different names and higher numbers. I'm not sure how they can even improve it with the game being how it is.

Housing is another matter, they mention server strain but given their past comments on what is and isn't possible (like showing what items you own), coupled with their terrible netcode, I'm inclined to not trust them on this one. As you say they are great at the game side of things, but seem to struggle with the tech side.

[ Parent | on HN ]