Checking the extent of the vulnerability is a reasonable thing to do before reporting it. This is more "you have left all your doors unlocked" than "I stole all your stuff".
This guy has done the company a huge favor by actually demonstrating the problem.
That said, I can see the temptation to want an answer to the question "did the really leave every account open?"
"I found your private diary in the hedge near your house, so I had a bit of a rummage around and also found your cheque book, credit card and driver's license. There's probably more stuff as well. Just thought I'd let you know before anyone else finds them"
They aren't some online shopping store. They are a trustee.
The company hasn't lost anything, while both examples talk about 'taking away' and 'you want it back?'. This is the standard copy != theft analogy failure.
Note that I do understand that the company (and people affected as customers) wouldn't want him to keep a backup of whatever data he copied. Still, please don't compare it to theft, robbery or whatever.
Seriously? That sounds a little more than just "Checking the vulnerability exists", that sounds like exploiting it. Tweaking the url, is all he needed to do to workout that there was a problem... then he writes a script and downloads all the data?
I'm actually not that shocked by the reaction. Equivelant:
"I noticed your door was unlocked, so I stole all your stuff, and put it in that truck parked just there. Just thought you might like to know". <--- Would you take legal action in that case?