Re:On Political Belief
by barrkel on Monday October 17, 2011 @11:58PM
(#3123821)
Groups using simple majority vote cannot hold logically consistent positions, so it is an absolute necessity that those elected for office contradict a majority of the voters.
Specifically, logical conjunction does not hold for voting groups. Imagine three people, X, Y and Z; and some proposition P which is true if A and B are true. Suppose X believes in A, Y believes in B, and Z believes in A and B. So vote on A: does a majority believe in A? Yes, both X and Z do. Does a majority believe in B: Yes, both Y and Z. But does a majority believe in P (which is necessarily true if both A and B are true)? No, only Z believes in P. So conjunction (i.e. the AND operator) does not hold for groups; and without conjunction, consistent logic is impossible.
Specifically, logical conjunction does not hold for voting groups. Imagine three people, X, Y and Z; and some proposition P which is true if A and B are true. Suppose X believes in A, Y believes in B, and Z believes in A and B. So vote on A: does a majority believe in A? Yes, both X and Z do. Does a majority believe in B: Yes, both Y and Z. But does a majority believe in P (which is necessarily true if both A and B are true)? No, only Z believes in P. So conjunction (i.e. the AND operator) does not hold for groups; and without conjunction, consistent logic is impossible.