Re:4chan's Chris Poole: Facebook & Google Are Doing It Wrong
by endtime on Monday October 17, 2011 @10:55PM
(#3123644)
How is that not isomorphic to Circles?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:4chan's Chris Poole: Facebook & Google Are Doing It Wrong
by slowpoke on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @02:33AM
(#3124130)
It's not. You seem to have misread the article. moot's saying that it's important "who you share as" not "who you share with". G+ doesn't allow you to have multiple identities, it allows you to share in different contexts with the same identity - which is fundamentally different.
Besides, it's a very bad idea to leave identity management in the hands of a third party anyways, and the last third party I'd trust with my identities are Google and Facebook. Call me paranoid all you want, but identities are something you manage yourself - nobody should be trusted doing it for you.
Re:4chan's Chris Poole: Facebook & Google Are Doing It Wrong
by endtime on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @05:19PM
(#3127244)
I didn't misread anything. What I'm saying is that sharing "as" a different aspect of myself is functionally equivalent to sharing with a different Circle, from a privacy perspective.