News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by gruez on Monday May 02, 2022 @08:55AM (#31234513)
>Animal protein is not a problem. There is plenty of land in the US only suitable for grazing

Only in the sense that you can theoretically produce meat that way, but in reality most meat is produced on CAFOs that use grain.

Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by m0llusk on Monday May 02, 2022 @12:46PM (#31237528)
The truth is more complex than that. Most beef is mostly pastured then finished with grains. And the grains used mostly hulls and other parts of grains considered inappropriate for human consumption.
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by kickout on Monday May 02, 2022 @09:29AM (#31234855)
they do this because its most efficient/profitable, not because of a technical limitation. Those economic incentivizes could be changed rapidly given the proper political capital.
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by gruez on Monday May 02, 2022 @09:54AM (#31235144)
I don't think we're disagreeing here. I already admitted in my previous comment that it was theoretically possible. My point was that even though it's possible for animal protein to be "not a problem", that's not the case today.
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by wbsss4412 on Monday May 02, 2022 @12:08PM (#31237006)
They do it because it dramatically increases yield.

Feeding cows grain in a CAFO setting allows them to rapidly put on weight and turnover their herds faster. Not doing so would result in dramatically lower yields per acre of grassland.

Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by legulere on Monday May 02, 2022 @11:24AM (#31236323)
It‘s done because grasslands cannot support meat consumption of the world.
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by Gordonjcp on Monday May 02, 2022 @11:54AM (#31236779)
But they can supply the meat consumption of the areas with grasslands.
[dead]
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by kickout on Monday May 02, 2022 @11:57AM (#31236838)
I mean, this comment is wrong. The US has some of the world most stringent food standards in the world. FDA, USDA, OSHA etc. wield immense regulatory power. Is it perfect? No. You can't sell meat at scale in the USA without the government signing off.

It may not be up to your or mine standard, but it has proven successful at getting _quality_ meat into the mouths of millions.

Also, I would bet there aren't any cattle housed in a desert in the USA. They'd die immediately due to heat because no way anybody is paying for AC for _cattle_

Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by magicalist on Monday May 02, 2022 @12:31PM (#31237348)
> I mean, this comment is wrong. The US has some of the world most stringent food standards in the world. FDA, USDA, OSHA etc. wield immense regulatory power. Is it perfect? No. You can't sell meat at scale in the USA without the government signing off.

> It may not be up to your or mine standard, but it has proven successful at getting _quality_ meat into the mouths of millions.

The GP was maybe a little hyperbolic with "basically no food quality standards", but I don't think "regulatory agencies exist therefore you're wrong" is any better.

A lot of people would likely be alarmed at the lack of standards for cattle feed. You can't feed dead cow brains back to cows, for instance, but you can use lots of other parts of dead cows for feed for other animals, and then those animals (and their manure) can be used in feed for cows. And this distinction is almost entirely self enforced by workers whose jobs are largely only rewarded for throughput.

> Also, I would bet there aren't any cattle housed in a desert in the USA. They'd die immediately due to heat because no way anybody is paying for AC for _cattle_

You'd be wrong. There are a lot of cattle raised in the Chihuahuan Desert and surrounding arid regions, as just one example.

Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by Supermancho on Monday May 02, 2022 @02:04PM (#31238584)
> There are a lot of cattle raised in the Chihuahuan Desert

The cattle in southern california (Corona) were moved en-masse to the central valley as conditions have changed. Grazing traditionally moves north against the global warming trend.

Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by nicoburns on Monday May 02, 2022 @05:01PM (#31240878)
> The US has some of the world most stringent food standards in the world.

I can think of at least two issues I have with US food standards:

- Very few restrictions on pesticide use. There are nasty chemicals ending up on your food and killing off a lot of the biodiversity where it grows

- Antibiotics being fed to livestock. Not good for them, and practically begging for antibiotic-resistant pathogens to develop.

[dead]
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by Supermancho on Monday May 02, 2022 @02:03PM (#31238574)
The protection goes both ways, you vs the meat and meat vs YOU.
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by wbsss4412 on Monday May 02, 2022 @12:10PM (#31237046)
No, the most commonly consumed meats do not come from ruminants. Pigs and chickens are the most commonly eaten animals in the world by a substantial margin and they aren’t feeding on grass.
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by mythrwy on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @11:22AM (#31249424)
It's possible to graze chickens. They will eat grass (along with insects and anything else they find).

Search Joel Salatin for more info. He has a number of sustainable local systems for chickens, pigs etc.

Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by wbsss4412 on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:11PM (#31250753)
It may be possible, but that doesn’t mean we could maintain anywhere near our current levels of output if we were to switch chickens over to grazing.

The only way to sustain this level of meat consumption is by utilizing the current industrial practices.

Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by mythrwy on Tuesday May 03, 2022 @01:21PM (#31250893)
There _may_ be other ways but in general ya, I agree. Organic small plot won't feed the world at these levels and price points. No argument.

I just thought it was interesting that possibly chickens could be run on more marginal land as cattle are now.

This might become more attractive if fertilizer prices keep going up.

Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by Gordonjcp on Monday May 02, 2022 @12:21PM (#31237200)
You can still use pig and chicken shit to grow crops, and indeed that's what they use a lot of round here.
Re:Historic fertilizer crunch threatens food security by wbsss4412 on Monday May 02, 2022 @12:39PM (#31237447)
Yes, but that is an entirely separate line of discussion. Your assertion was that “pretty much all meat comes from grassland”, which is very much incorrect.

If your point here is that manure from pigs and chickens makes up for the grain inputs needed to raise them, you would also be incorrect.