News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by klyrs on Sunday May 01, 2022 @04:21PM (#31228304)
> Musk... said during a recent earnings call ... "My personal guess is that we’ll achieve Full Self-Driving this year at a safety level significantly greater than a person..."

Does this guy ever get tired of saying "this year" and "next year" every year and being wrong every single time? Do his investors?

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by burnnn on Sunday May 01, 2022 @04:28PM (#31228355)
As a developer, I completely understand this.

loop:

Manager: how long will this feature take?

SWE: By lunchtime, tops

3 weeks later:

Manager: feature complete, right?

SWE (sweating bullets): We're just testing the final bits

goto loop

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by bussierem on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:06PM (#31229963)
Except the part where you don't have people throwing _very_ large quantities of money at you based on these estimates, such that when/if you're wrong it could potentially spell disaster for an entire company costing shareholder money and peoples' livelihoods/jobs.

I'm not trying to claim that each individual claim of Musk's has this potential behind it, but equating it to day-to-day situations of underestimating the difficulty of a small task at your day-job oversimplifies the matter way too much and just makes excuses for someone who should TRULY know better.

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by Gordonjcp on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:18PM (#31229264)
> at a safety level significantly greater than a person

Have they actually achieved that yet? It seems like the Teslas can only do their Autopilot magic on more-or-less straight motorways with every other car travelling at the same speed in clear weather conditions.

These are circumstances in which human drivers don't have accidents, either.

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by PlanckMeasure80 on Sunday May 01, 2022 @08:42PM (#31230184)
Have you ever driven one? I got to drive one for a few days.

It handled heavy rain. It knew where the lines were even though I couldn’t even see them myself. It does really well even when there are no lines.

It does turns and exits. It slows down automatically for curves. It even swerved out of the way when someone was merging into me. It was fine with drivers going faster and slower than myself.

Frankly, I have no idea what you’re talking about, especially regarding a clear day and straight lines.

It drove better than me. In my use case, the 2021 Model 3 is already practically self-driving. I legitimately felt less safe while manual operating the vehicle.

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by Gordonjcp on Monday May 02, 2022 @03:18AM (#31232235)
I have, yes. It was a pretty scary experience, to be honest. It doesn't anticipate other drivers' actions, it just reacts - so it was always getting into dangerous situations like having to swerve out of the way of people merging into lanes. It worked okay in the dark, but not dark and rain, and not really in the rain particularly, which makes it not very useful on the West Coast of Scotland. It only works on motorways and dual carriageways, which, again, make it not very useful.

It doesn't work on single-lane roads so I wasn't able to find out if it can see deer, sheep, cows, or other animals. It probably can.

It's like being driven by a drunk teenager, because it doesn't anticipate, reacts late, and cannot cope with developing situations.

I don't really see the point in them. Why would you want a self-driving car anyway?

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by panick21_ on Monday May 02, 2022 @05:21AM (#31232849)
Wait, in Scotland?

That means you don't actually have the FSD Beta.

That's a totally different software stack.

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by Gordonjcp on Monday May 02, 2022 @12:22PM (#31237221)
Right, but I can't see it being any better than autopilot.

It still doesn't answer the question "why would I want that?", either.

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by panick21_ on Monday May 02, 2022 @03:02PM (#31239369)
> I can't see

You can't be serious with that argument.

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by slaw on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:15PM (#31230723)
If it drives better than you, why don’t you take back seat?
Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by sidibe on Monday May 02, 2022 @09:58PM (#31243528)
"for legal reasons". After all that is the only reason there is a driver according to tesla.com/autopilot. And that's 5 years old, so surely we should feel comfortable in the back seat by now besides the law
Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by jackvalentine on Sunday May 01, 2022 @09:26PM (#31230452)
> It handled heavy rain. It knew where the lines were even though I couldn’t even see them myself. It does really well even when there are no lines.

It knew, or it guessed and presented it as it knew in the same way humans guess where the lines are and keep driving when they’re not visible?

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by panick21_ on Monday May 02, 2022 @05:20AM (#31232839)
He himself says at least half that time his predictions are wrong. His predictions were always aggressive.

He says what he believes, this topic is where he has totally miscalculated. And he recently admired that but said he just has to look at what he think the current fundamental problem is and when it will be solved.

> Do his investors?

Mhh as an investor I would say, no.

Because for me its not about matching prediction but its about overall strategy and the competition.

If there were millions of self driving taxis on the road from the competition I would suggest that is a big problem. However that is not case.

Massive investment in this is the correct thing to do in my opinion. Their approach is correct in my opinion, they are trying to solve the hard problem. They have done many things that no competitor has even remotely done.

So I am happy even if he miss predicts this for the next 4 years unless there is continues progress and the competition has not 100% solved the problem.

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by phenkdo on Sunday May 01, 2022 @05:01PM (#31228638)
The non-sinner line starts over there, and goes round the block.
Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by klyrs on Sunday May 01, 2022 @05:51PM (#31229050)
Loving the Bible-themed whataboutism. Musk has definitely paid for some extremely cool stuff to happen, but it's fair to point out that he's been making this particular promise since 2014.

And nobody dies if I break a promise. Autopilot/FSD has claimed quite a few lives, in large part because it doesn't live up to the hype coming out of Musk's mouth.

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by panick21_ on Monday May 02, 2022 @03:11PM (#31239469)
So you count anybody that fell asleep or didn't pay attention as a 'kill' for Autopilot (and that number is very small) while you totally ignore all the times the same software prevented accidents (a very large number).

I guess that one way to analyses issues if you already have a result that you want to happen.

Re:Tesla Accused of Cutting Corner That Makes Level 3 Self-D... by paulmendoza on Sunday May 01, 2022 @09:35PM (#31230499)
He is restricting his statements more. I think what he said is probably possible this year.