And the article doesn't make much sense to me. While I don't agree with everything Cook does, Recent Apple computers are traditional Apple at its best — extremely well designed, minimalist, functional, with best in class performance, displays and portability.
The iPhone 5c was not a device for executives.
The 5c flopped because of other reasons: it was artificially made worse than the 5s. It started with 8GB memory that was already WAY TOO LITTLE back then, it had no touchid, it had a bad camera and so much more - and yet, the price was high. Apple learned from the mistakes and changed their segmentation strategy and it worked since then (with the exception of the weird XR thing).
People like big phones. The idea of a big iPhone that has contemporary guts but lacks some of the really wild camera abilities of the Max models didn’t inherently seem like the wrong plan to me. But it just kinda went nowhere, probably because you can just go buy last year’s iPhone model.
Now they have the approach to have a full price standard model - and there is a super duper "pro" model for the extra successful, professional and rich people.
This approach makes more sense for the consumers and this makes the 12 and 13 fly the way they do.
A lot of the iOS 7 changes were positive, and those which were missteps were far from "disastrous" and have already been reversed.
If you have to go all the way back to a fringe product like the 5c, that kinda proves the opposite of your point, doesn't it? The 5c is the exception that proves the rule.
Nobody should be glad Ive is gone. It was a tremendous loss. For every decision you might disagree with, there were a hundred others that were spot-on.
His value existed solely when his extremes were moderated by someone like Steve Jobs.
When handed the reigns, Ive ran roughshod over what made Apple — and his own work — worthwhile. He prioritized form over function, and ego over empathy.
This goes for iOS 7 and the iPhone 5c as well, no?
Eg. The clean aluminum case and the black keys etc. It looks fundamentally the same.
Contrast with the butterfly keyboard, which was new in a post jobs world. And universally a disaster.
Let's consider Jony's performance on software design first. This is what some prominent people have said about iOS 7: The Verge wrote in their review: "iOS 7 isn't harder to use, just less obvious. That's a momentous change: iOS used to be so obvious." Michael Heilemann, Interface Director at Squarespace wrote, "when I look at [iOS 7 beta] I see anti-patterns and basic mistakes that should have been caught on the whiteboard before anyone even began thinking about coding it." And famed blogger John Gruber said this about iOS 7: "my guess is that [Steve Jobs] would not have supported this direction."
And what about Jony's other responsibility, industrial design? The iPod, iPhone, iPad, MacBook Air and other Apple products from Jobs era are all amazingly well designed and breathtakingly beautiful. But these products weren't designed by Jony Ive all by himself. He designed them under Steve Jobs's guidance and direction. Steve was the tastemaker. Apple's post-Steve products are nowhere near as well-designed.
Consider iPhone 5c, for example. The colors were horrid, and when you added those Crocs-like cases it looked more like a Fisher-Price toy than like a device an executive would want to be seen holding. That the 5c didn't do well in the market shouldn't surprise anyone.
As an Apple shareholder and customer I am glad Ive is gone.