Re:Removing characters from strings faster with AVX-512
by XorNot on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:04AM
(#31225088)
Why would it be irrelevant? Even the paucity of availability isn't really a problem - the big winners here are server users in data centers, not desktops or laptops. How much string parsing and munging is happening ingesting big datasets right now? If running a specially optimized function set on part of your fleet reduces utilization, that's direct cost savings you realize. If the AMD is then widening that support base, you're deeply favoring expanding usage while you scale up.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Removing characters from strings faster with AVX-512
by _rtld_global_ro on Sunday May 01, 2022 @10:17AM
(#31225181)
Given Intel's AVX extension could cause silent failures on servers (very high work load for prolonged time, compare to end user computers), I'm not sure it would be a big win for servers either: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2102.11245.pdf.
Re:Removing characters from strings faster with AVX-512
by jcranmer on Sunday May 01, 2022 @11:21AM
(#31225725)
I'm downvoting you because the assertion you're implying--that use of AVX increases soft failure rates more than using non-AVX instructions would--is not sustained by the source you use as reference.
Re:Removing characters from strings faster with AVX-512
by tialaramex on Sunday May 01, 2022 @11:57AM
(#31226075)
Indeed, I'd summarise that source as "At Facebook sometimes weird stuff happens. We postulate it's not because of all the buggy code written by Software Engineers like us, it must be hardware. As well as lots of speculation about hypothetical widespread problems that would show we're actually not writing buggy software, here's a single concrete example where it was hardware".
If anything I'd say that Core 59 is one of those exceptions that prove the rule. This is such a rare phenomenon that when it does happen you can do the work to pin it down and say yup, this CPU is busted - if it was really commonplace you'd constantly trip over these bugs and get nowhere. There probably isn't really, as that paper claims, a "systemic issue across generations" except that those generations are all running Facebook's buggy code.
Re:Removing characters from strings faster with AVX-512
by janwas on Sunday May 01, 2022 @01:35PM
(#31226906)
One interesting anecdote is that HPC planning for exascale included significant concern about machine failures and (silent) data corruption. When running at large enough scale, even seemingly small failure rates translate into "oh, there goes another one".