append is the opposite of magic. it's exposing the details of a realloc when 99% of the time you want to keep the same binding. That's probably also why map doesn't have an equivalent; in the case of hash tables it's more like 99.999%.
Re:Experience Report: 6 months of Go
by nemothekid on Saturday April 30, 2022 @07:31PM
(#31220512)
>append is the opposite of magic
You cannot write the append function in pre-go 1.18. That is what I mean by magic. The reason it's given to you because it would be painful to build a function like append for every slice type. That's also why it gets to have blessed nil properties.
Well, you could, using unsafe. But you also couldn't write the index operator (without unsafe), and I don't think anyone would call that "magic". And in either case that has nothing to do with its treatment of nil.
It would be more magic if it somehow updated a hidden pointer, like maps do. (And this has also been my experience teaching Go, people grasp quickly that slice length/cap is immutable but often forget that non-nil maps are mutable and always "by reference".)
But why isn't there an `assign` function? I've been writing Go for a long time, and from a design point of view, I really don't like append. It's magic, and as the OP has shown, it's trips up new programmers. If Go was consistent, there shouldn't be an append; but instead we got "generics for this one function". The problem isn't really `nil` that acts confusing (in this case), it's `append` acting like a function when it's really a magic compiler directive.
I personally think this criticism is a problem; zero-values, especially nil ones, can be a major footgun. I've had a couple experiences where a production service crashed because someone accidentally tried to use a nil interface even though they had already nil-checked it.