News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Top navy admiral wants rust-free ships by Brian_K_White on Saturday April 30, 2022 @01:25PM (#31217567)
"Because I’m replying to someone who would know what those acronyms are."

That only flies in an email or on a specialized forum.

It's curious that you are smart enough to come up with an arguement yet apparently at the same time innocently simple enough not to know why it's invalid.

Re:Top navy admiral wants rust-free ships by unethical_ban on Saturday April 30, 2022 @01:44PM (#31217727)
>That only flies in an email or on a specialized forum.

Counterpoint: It doesn't.

They made a reply to a military member on a thread about military equipment. Googling a few acronyms + "military" would surely lead one to the answer.

Re:Top navy admiral wants rust-free ships by andrewaylett on Saturday April 30, 2022 @05:29PM (#31219561)
It would indeed. But why push the burden onto all the non-specialist readers, who after all come here to both learn and to take part, rather than expand the initialisms the first time they're introduced in a thread?

I'm reminded of an acronym at work: CIM. They come in two variants, CIM-A and CIM-B. I'd been there a year before I finally decided I needed to ask a more senior colleague what they stood for, and he didn't know either. The intention was obvious from the context of their use (although whether -A or -B was more serious wasn't) but most of the people in the weekly meetings discussing Critical Incident Management didn't actually know that was what they were discussing. Nowadays we have a culture that better encourages definition of terms upon first use, and it's less common that someone needs to ask "stupid" questions.

Re:Top navy admiral wants rust-free ships by jwithington on Saturday April 30, 2022 @02:03PM (#31217872)
lol I feel like this debate plays out at least weekly in a HN thread about a subculture, specialty, etc.