News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Saturday April 30, 2022 @07:33AM (#31215201)
> Christianity likely still had happend and so our current world might not be all that different…

I don‘t know about Christianity. I think that without the conversion of Constantine, Christianity would have at best been something like Baháʼí is today, a relatively small, persecuted religion. It was Constantine’s conversion and the subsequent adoption of Christianity by the Roman Emperors that made Christianity what it is.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by cmrdporcupine on Saturday April 30, 2022 @08:44AM (#31215618)
Yes, and the thing is that many of the trappings of at least the Catholic church reflect a strong "Romanization" of the religion and the fusion of various "pagan" elements (stylistic and ritualistic) of Roman or Mithraic pagainism into the practice. Vestal virgins to nuns, etc.

Christianity without a powerful pan-Roman culture may have stayed as a kind of messaniac Jewish sect, confined to Jewish communities around the mediteranean.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by ithkuil on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:08PM (#31217039)
Perhaps the appeal of Christianity was just happenstance or perhaps it hit a sweet spot that would have worked well even a large empire (with a large number of slaves etc) that would have originated from a Punic civilization and its religion, myths, culture.

It would have likely looked very different from this Christianity, possibly to the point that we'd barely recognize any similarity.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by cmrdporcupine on Monday May 02, 2022 @10:18AM (#31235429)
It probably would have looked a lot like Islam.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by tomrod on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:32PM (#31217198)
No dog in this fight, having left Christianity in leaving behind a tumultuous youth -- but question.

Why aren't Coptic christian sects more representative of what would have happened without Christianity usurping/inheriting Roman authority?

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by cmrdporcupine on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:58PM (#31219281)
I'm no expert, but think the Coptic sects accepted early Roman orthodoxy, participated in the various councils, adopted the Nicene creed, condemned the various heresies, etc. So they differ extensively from the rather heterogenous beliefs and practices of the church of 1st and 2nd century.

In a way, maybe Islam is closer to what you're suggesting. A monotheistic religion without the dominance of the Roman empire or influence from it, and without the rather odd violent debates about the trinity and the relationship of Christ to God etc. that went on in early Church

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by abecedarius on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:36PM (#31217218)
The empire created the conditions for a 'pandemic'-style spread of religion in a meme-o-sphere unadapted to such -- and probably any Mediterranean-wide integrated economy would've been similar in that way.

Some features of the winning religion seem convergent (e.g. intolerance to rivals). But I think expecting Christianity in particular would be like expecting a rewind of evolution to end up at humans.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by zozbot234 on Saturday April 30, 2022 @01:14PM (#31217491)
Christianity was not really a small religion in the earliest centuries of the Common Era. It was adopted by the Roman elite relatively quickly, partly because its unique cosmopolitanism and appeal among the lower classes meant it meshed very well with the open-minded Stoic ideals that would've been common back then.