News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by thriftwy on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:31AM (#31214358)
Maybe the ancient civilization will not collapse and we would have smartphones and satellites around year 1000 AD.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by wwtrv on Saturday April 30, 2022 @05:31AM (#31214598)
Technological progress didn't really stop when 'ancient' civilizations collapsed. First of all it was hardly happening in the first place, most people were subsistence farmers and their lives hardly changed when the Library of Alexandria burnt down or Christian emperors stopped funding the Academy in Athens.

Also the 'dark ages' weren't really as dark as some might think. Arguably most of the decline was a result of climate change and the plague, which lead to a collapse of urban populations, which were the centers of literacy and education. However technological progress didn't really stop, there were significant improvements in metallurgy and agriculture and by the high middle ages Europeans were much more 'advanced' in almost every area compared to ~400 AD.

The one thing ancient empires were exceptionally good was concentrating resources, e.g. no state was able to field a standing army in the hundreds of thousands and no city even came close to the population Rome had until the 19th century but that was due to political reasons (shipping tons of grain half across the (known) world to fed a massive unproductive urban population just to shore up some political support simply wasn't viable anymore).

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by cmrdporcupine on Saturday April 30, 2022 @08:49AM (#31215652)
Certainly the economic contraction in the west was real and looked very much like a "collapse." But it was as much a product of frequence plagues with corresponding population loss as it was of some more systemic civilizational collapse.

In the east, in Anatolia, the Roman civilization lived on with quite a bit more vibrancy and power than people often recognize.

But in places like Britain it's pretty night and day: early 5th century still a predominantly Christian Roman province speaking Latin and Brythonic, by the end a predominantly Saxon speaking mostly non-Christian population with drastically reduced economic activity and wealth.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by achillesheels on Saturday April 30, 2022 @10:17AM (#31216237)
So the roads were not paved after the 4th century due to plague and not a failed civilized administration? Would you consider the Merovingians as civilized as the Phoenicians?
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by cmrdporcupine on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:38PM (#31217235)
I think the story is really one of the failure of the ability to raise taxes for the maintenance of armies and civil infrastructure rather than some inherent "civilized" or "uncivilized" character of any particular people.

You can't raise taxes when half or more of the population is gone. As per WP: "Some historians believe the first plague pandemic was one of the deadliest pandemics in history, resulting in the deaths of an estimated 15–100 million people during two centuries of recurrence, a death toll equivalent to 25–60% of Europe's population at the time of the first outbreak"

And this is after a couple generations of political turmoil, other plagues, and invasions.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by wwtrv on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:03PM (#31216998)
We know remarkably little about the Phoenicians, though. So it's not really a fair comparison, based on what we do and by modern standards Merovingians would probably be considered to be more civilized.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by wwtrv on Saturday April 30, 2022 @10:31AM (#31216353)
There is archeological evidence that Saxons and other Germans had started settling in Britain well before the Romans officially left. They had almost successfully invaded Britain back in 367. And many had settled in Britain and seemed to be somewhat integrated into the local society, Germans served in the Roman army, their villages were in close proximity to Roman roads and settlements, indicating that that both groups managed to coexist at least somewhat peacefully of for a time. Over time Saxons seemed to have displaced the local Romano-British elite. However this process probably took at least several generations and probably had little effect on the lifestyles of most ordinary people. While the disappearance of the Roman legions must had been a shock, the transition from mainly Christian Latin and Brythonic speakers to pagan Saxons was fairly slow and probably took several hundreds of years.

Also we don't really know Christian Britain was before the Saxon conquests, it's not unlikely that most British people outside of urban settlements were still pagan and only superficially Christianized. We also don't really know did the British people become culturally Saxon. According what was written down by the surviving members of the Romano-British elite it was a result of genocidal conquest. However the predominant view of modern historians seems to be that the process was much more peaceful and more akin to the Arabization of the Middle East and North Africa (i.e. the conquerors established a dual class system which incentivized the local population to adopt the Saxon language and culture because of the economic and social advantages. Also, unless the Saxons were significantly more brutal, oppressive and numerous than the Franks, Goths and other invaders this would imply that the local Britons weren't actually thoroughly Christianized since Christian populations were usually able to resist this type of Cultural conversion).

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by cmrdporcupine on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:32PM (#31217193)
There's a lot here to respond to, and in the end it's mostly speculation, but a few things.

In regards to the comparison between Franks and Goths and Saxons, it's not really the same. In those cases they took over the existing Roman state and continued its administration, leaving the institiutions of civil society much the same and even adopting Latin as a language and Roman cultural practices for themselves within a couple generations.

By the time the Saxons arrived en masse in what is now England the existing Roman administration had pretty much collapsed. That seems to be the archaeological evidence in my recent reading: drastic declines in the economic vibrancy of British communities. Things like amphorae and other mediterannean trade goods vanishing. Rich people burying their wealth to hide it from invaders. And, yeah, the stories told by Gildas & St Patrick, our only real contemporary accounts from this general period, seem to agree with this: decline of local British power, retreating into small cloistered communities, Saxon (and other Germanic) raiders wea continual pest even in Roman times, yes, but after the departure of the Roman administration it becoming drastically more aggrivated, the locals were incapable of defending themselves, and the British turned to Germanic mercenaries as a defense (a common Roman tactic). Which predictably backfired.

I've read two books commenting on this period of British history recently, and both disagree remarkably on the degree of cultural and physical replacement. But on the whole the genetic and archaeological and linguistic evidence seems to me to support the statements by Gildas and St Patrick: the British were on the whole replaced & expelled (to Wales, Cornwall or Brittany), or exterminated. This is reflected in part by the fact that only a few Saxon settlements carried forward on top of existing Romano-British settlements, and most adopted new names entirely. Even some prominent ones like London were left pretty much uninhabited for generations before being re-settled later.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by wwtrv on Saturday April 30, 2022 @06:18PM (#31219965)
Population replacement seems to had been significant but in no way total, the ancestry of modern the population of eastern England (which was conquered/settled first) is around 40% Anglo-Saxon/Continental Germanic (however the influx of Germans continued well after the 5th century and we can't really genetically distinguish the Saxons/other Germans and the Vikings/Norse whose came centuries later). Of course we don't really know what happened to the local people, many might have fled west or to Armorica, there are some hypothesis that the native Briton population was more heavily hit by the plague and/or that south east England was already significantly depopulated during the 4th century, many were undoubtedly murdered however it seems that the majority (or at least a number exceeding that of the invading Saxons) survived and were integrated into the new Saxon society one way or the other.

There is evidence that there was at least some degree of peaceful coexistence between Saxons and local British at least in the early periods of settlement. There are burial sites where both genetically British and German (or mixed) people were buried together, with identical grave goods and seemingly with no distinction. This would indicate that at least some local people adopted Saxon customs and language and were accepted as equal members of their society. However this is not exactly conclusive, there are also many segregated burial sites so the type of interaction between the local Britons and the German invaders/settlers varied by area and time period, it took them well over 200 years to almost fully conquer the territory of modern England.

Gildas and St Patrick were members of the Romano-British landowning elite which was displaced by the Saxons, I'm trying to dispute their authenticity but their experience might not have been representative of the majority of local people (who were never fully romanized or integrated into the roman society). It would not be completely surprising if local Britons decided that they would be better off by 'switching sides' and adopting Saxon/German culture. Of course we don't know how widespread and voluntary the process could had been, however according to genetic evidence it must have occurred to some extent.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by cmrdporcupine on Saturday April 30, 2022 @06:24PM (#31220020)
Sometimes I fantasize we'll unearth some long lost documents and get more background on how things were then. For some reason the period fascinates me.

But, yeah, unlikely.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by inglor_cz on Saturday April 30, 2022 @01:24PM (#31217558)
One of the things that undoubtedly went down was the level of literacy. Plenty of secular Roman citizens were literate and there were many schools for young Romans who wished to find lucrative employment.

Once Rome fell, the educational system outside the Church disappeared entirely for almost a millennium and the Church remained the only institution that carried on the tradition of reading and writing in the West.

This must have had some impact on the tempo of overall technological progress. Just like the fact that the successor states, unable to concentrate resources as much, couldn't start big public works (channels, aqueducts) which used to require a lot of highly qualified people.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by wwtrv on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:12PM (#31229215)
That's true, the decline in literacy was significant, but this is to large degree an outcome of the collapse of urban populations, even during Roman times there were relatively few literate people in the countryside. And "almost a millennium" is probably stretching it a bit, for example in Tuscany (and presumably other regions of Northern/Central Italy) most small towns or even villagers seemed to already have teachers by the 12th century and in richer cities like Florence at least the majority of boys attended a primary at least for some time (by the 14th century it's estimated that up to 30-35% of the people living in Florence could read, of course being one the richest and most developed cities in Western Europe this was probably an outlier, but then again even during the Roman times literacy probably varied significantly between Italy, the Greek cities in the east and places like Gaul or Britain).
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by lettergram on Saturday April 30, 2022 @09:51AM (#31216079)
“It wasn’t a collapse, technology / economy stagnated or reduced for 600-1200 years”

I think most people would consider that a “dark age” or “collapse”.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by wwtrv on Saturday April 30, 2022 @11:38AM (#31216838)
Well there was a collapse, but it "only" lasted for 100 to 200 years and no anything close to 600. Populations in Mediterranean and European decreased sharply between 5th and 6th centuries due to the plague and climate change and growth remained modest until the medieval warm period. However there was nothing the people living at the time could have realistically done to avoid this.

However outside of that period it's not that straightforward. The Roman economy was stagnant or declining well before the Western empire officially collapsed. According to some historians growth in much of the Mediterranean region stopped with the Roman conquests at the end of the Hellenistic period. But even if we assume that ~200 A.D. was the peak can we really say that there was more technological innovation and economic growth between the 3rd - 5th centuries than between the 8th and 10th centuries? Probably the latter..

And it also varied significantly depending on the area we're talking about. Italy probably took the longest to recover but it's economy was massively inflated due to wealth transfers during the Roman period. However the center of economic and political power in Europe has shifted to the other side of the alps France and Germany had nearly the double the population in 1000 AD compared to their Roman peaks. And some places like mainland Greece arguably never did until the 19th century (it was probably was past it's peak during the Roman period as well, though. A similar process occurred in the eastern Mediterranean where the center of power shifted from the coast to the inland areas (like the area modern day Iraq).

And we're only taking about absolute growth here, per capita productivity probably wasn't as much affected and most of the decline in international trade (which eventually recovered) was balanced out by higher availability of land (per capita) and improvements in agricultural techniques and tools.

If we're talking about technological growth, well again in some areas like architecture the decline was severe and near total (most communities couldn't afford to maintain the buildings they already had). In other areas the reverse might had happened, based on archeological evidence the average quality of metal tools and weapons in Western Europe was already much better in the 7-8th centuries compared to what the Romans ever had. The heavy plow was introduced in agriculture, water mills continued to be built. Literacy rates fell, however that was to a large degree an outcome of the collapse of urban populations. However the link between economic and technological progress and education in the ancient world wasn't all that clear.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by jl6 on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:57AM (#31214470)
Uncollapsed civilizations aren’t necessarily sources of progress. Stability can lead to stagnation. A more reliable driver of innovation towards modernity is war. Perhaps if the ancient Roman state had had a strong persistent competitor in the form of a resilient Carthage, they would have spurred each other on to make more rapid progress.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by qiskit on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:12PM (#31217059)
Civilizations have to collapse for progress. Civilizations always stagnate. Otherwise, the mesopotamians, ancient egyptians, ancient chinese, ancient indians, etc would have given us smartphones. If it is civilizations' nature to continually progress, the aztecs or incas or mayans in the americas would have had space ships by the time columbus arrived to exterminate them.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by dr_dshiv on Saturday April 30, 2022 @08:52AM (#31215665)
I love alt historical thinking. What would have been the big shifts in the tech tree? Literacy to moveable type would have done wonders. And coal. And banking. I think that would have been enough. Monotheism was a disaster for intellectual development.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by lettergram on Saturday April 30, 2022 @10:02AM (#31216154)
> Monotheism was a disaster for intellectual development

I don’t know if the facts actually back that up.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by tomrod on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:34PM (#31217211)
China, a polytheistic/non-theistic culture in those times, being the progenitor of many fundamental technologies, even while ultimately failing to propagate many of those technologies, is a good example.

If the intelligentsia are focused on climbing fruitless political ladders steeped in theology versus scientific endeavors, you have less progress overall.

Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by stjohnswarts on Saturday April 30, 2022 @12:46PM (#31217302)
Yeah that's seems silly, all religions tend to stunt scientific growth as they keep large swathes of people from being curious about why certain things happen and just "why?" in general.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by dr_dshiv on Saturday April 30, 2022 @02:16PM (#31217969)
Yeah, but polytheistic approaches at least allow for diversity of thought. Like the hermetic philosophies that influenced alchemy. Monotheism (the enforced kind) really stunted philosophy.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by wwtrv on Sunday May 01, 2022 @06:48PM (#31229485)
Religion provided a rules based framework on how the world works, it might have been absurd (from a modern viewpoint) and has largely outgrown it's purpose but humanity had to start somewhere and it's hard to imagine modern scientific method could had been developed without the foundation by built medieval theologians.
Re:Workers discover ‘unprecedented’ Phoenician necropolis in... by mr90210 on Saturday April 30, 2022 @04:39AM (#31214384)
That's a big if.