I think that makes it less testable but would probably work, it's probably a good stop gap as long as you don't want to test more than one "feature" at a time.
Gating would probably work better in the long term as you get more devs and users, and need to do things like A/B/C testing.
What about having two code bases on your production server and having your web server (nginx) route the traffic accordingly? 85% goes to the current code base and 15% goes to the new one?
If that's possible it would seem pretty easy.