Re:Introducing Instapaper 4.0 for iPad and iPhone
by nhangen on Monday October 17, 2011 @12:38PM
(#3121205)
I don't mind the length, in fact I prefer it, but you're right that Dan needs to jump in more often. My favorite podcasts on 5by5 are those in which Dan has a strong part in the discussion.
Re:Introducing Instapaper 4.0 for iPad and iPhone
by Tyrannosaurs on Tuesday October 18, 2011 @04:12AM
(#3124360)
Yep, it's not the length per se, it's the length to content ratio. Too often it feels they could have fitted the same stuff into a 30-40 minute show.
Re:Introducing Instapaper 4.0 for iPad and iPhone
by achompas on Monday October 17, 2011 @12:16PM
(#3121080)
Is the SE/SO podcast another example of unstructured dialogue? Or is it more structured?
Re:Introducing Instapaper 4.0 for iPad and iPhone
by mapgrep on Monday October 17, 2011 @01:41PM
(#3121505)
It is roughly as unstructured as a typical 5by5 podcast. There are often topics and/or guests selected in advance, with some or a lot of rambling.
(Personally, I like some rambling. A good podcast is like a good essay in that it will go off on tangents. But there needs to be unifying theme acting like gravity to reel the tangents back to Earth. For the StackOverflow podcast, the initial unifying theme was building StackOverflow, with the cofounders debating various decisions. With 5by5's The Talk Show it's typically one (or more) Apple events from the week plus a James Bond movie at the end. For The Pipeline and some other podcasts, the focus of each show is the guest who comes on the show that week.)
Whenever I see a weekly tech podcast of this sort clocking in around the hour mark my instant reaction is "you didn't prepare enough and you didn't edit enough".
See also the StackExchange / StackOverflow podcast.