Re:Show HN: Global Income Coin – Crypto UBI Project Backed b...
by randomhodler84 on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:15PM
(#31208806)
Oh I was there for AUR launch back in the day. I think I even bought some! Not a good purchase in retrospect.
There was another one around then too Mazacoin, distributing to First Nation folks.
The idea was good, but shitcoins cannot hold their value.
All these new folks refuse to learn the lessons of the past.
I like the idea of bottom up distribution! Thing is, you need to distribute something that people want, can use, and will hold its value on the long tail.
Blockchain is important for trustlessness between borders, that is all. LN tx don’t need blockchain txs for every spend — it’s state exchanges that can be committed to the chain on settlement.
Not that one try means all others will fail, but any new proposal must at least attempt to discover and overcome the factors of failures like that one. I don't see any such effort in this proposal.
Too bad, because overall, the idea of distributing new currency from the bottom up is vastly superior to any other distribution proposal. Giving directly to the population will create the largest multiplier effect as the velocity of that money will be highest — almost all of it will be spent, and re-spent in a matter of days, whereas going into the banking system it will both be delayed in effect and also have much fewer transactions/currency_unit.
But does it need a blockchain? Not convinced.