News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I want off Mr. Golang’s Wild Ride (2020) by andrewflnr on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:58PM (#31199716)
Note that a "dismissal" is not the same as an actual rebuttal. A template can just as easily generate a tricky-to-dissect fallacy or bad-faith argument as actual logic.
Re:I want off Mr. Golang’s Wild Ride (2020) by bawolff on Friday April 29, 2022 @05:29AM (#31203162)
I disagree - if its a template that is commonly used, someone only has to dissect it once.

Regardless, what exactly is tricky to disect or falacious about this template? The rebbutal is basically:

* go is trying to optimize for different things

* go makes no secret that its trying to optimize for different things

* some people like the things that go optimizes for (and some people don't).

* [with an implied] if you intentionally used a tool that made choices you don't like, and its not a secret they made those choices, is it really the tool's fault or your fault? Its like ordering ice cream and being mad the ice cream is cold.

If the original argument was more phrased as the types of design choices go makes are bad, it would probably be more palatable (but also less interesting, because whether worse really is better is flame war that has been going on for decades)

Re:I want off Mr. Golang’s Wild Ride (2020) by andrewflnr on Friday April 29, 2022 @02:07PM (#31208707)
You're too optimistic about defusing tricky BS. And I was deliberately avoiding making a claim about the article, only about the idea that the existence of a template to "dismiss" your argument implies anything about your argument. It does not.
Re:I want off Mr. Golang’s Wild Ride (2020) by bawolff on Friday April 29, 2022 @07:33PM (#31211816)
I think there are 2 senses of the word argument here. After all, how good your argument is (i.e. how good a job you do at convincing people of your view) has no bearing on how good your argument is (i.e. how true it is).

When i claim that failing to address a criticism that is so common it has a template form and thus should easily have been anticipated, makes for a bad argument, i mean in the first sense not the second. To be clear, by a template i mean a template response that people believe in good faith - like what was used in this discussion. I don't mean a template for making an ad hominem attack or something bad faith along those lines. But ultimately if there is some "tricky bullshit" that is commonly believed in good faith by the audience, then yes an argument that doesn't defuse it is a bad argument.