Agreed, but no-one is disputing that, right? The problem is that very often saying correctness was given up in order to gain velocity and simplicity is simply a lie. Incorrectness can easily lead to slow development and tons of complexity.
It’s only fun when the trade-off is actually a trade-off.
Rust is promoted for its correctness, but those correctness related bugs Rust prevents are an extremely low fraction of real world bugs (comparing to managed memory languages). I mean, how many type-system related bugs are there in real world projects with Java, C# or Go?
Rust is promoted with "fearless concurrency". Does it prevent your code from deadlocks, which are among the most tricky bugs?
unwrap() bugs are annoying, yes, but at the end of the day they're just a fancy assert(), helpfully spelled out in the code and confined to bits of it where the value is Option<T>. This is a much better situation than a language where nulls can in principle turn up anywhere.
I don't think that is clear at all in the general case. There's no reason why we should believe that "something had to be traded off to achieve it". In some cases probably that's what happened, maybe even explicitly, but in other cases there are just some designs that are better than others.
Nuance is exactly what I'm arguing for, there's none in the article.
> You even get to question my credentials a couple times! (I apparently pick metrics that are convenient to my argument, and fundamentally misunderstand programming language design).
You're right, I apologize. I usually try hard to never directly address whoever I'm responding to on HN, but figured it was fine since it's the linked article itself. It's clear to me now that reasoning makes no sense, I should have taken the time to reword it.
> I can't help but notice you carefully use the word "attempt" when referring to the promises Go /does/ make.
It's an acknowledgment that there's space to discuss Go failing to adhere to its design principles. I'd love to read an article on small changes to Go that would provide immense benefits. However, I don't see much value in an one-sided rant on the less-valued principles not being valued highly.
> correctness underpins /everything/, it's not a hobby
> [...]
> you don't get to choose not to care about "correctness". If you don't, you're just pushing the problem onto someone else.
Correctness isn't binary. It's perfectly valid to trade off correctness for gains elsewehere.
The classic example is companies switching from dynamic languages like Ruby to Go/Java once they hit scaling issues. Does that mean Ruby is a bad language and the company should have used Go/Java from the start? No. Using Ruby gave them the development velocity that let them get to scale in the first place.
If you do need strong correctness guarantees, by all means stay away from Go and use Rust/Ada/etc. Just remember that it's not free, something had to be traded off to achieve it.