News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by z3c0 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:42AM (#31190517)
Blockchains are cool. Very, very cool. Merkle trees on their own are pretty cool, and blockchains are just a Merkle tree hashed into a chain-like structure to create work for decentralized verification. This is a very clever concept, and it is the only known solution to the Byzantine Generals problem that doesn't involve a centralized authority (that I'm aware of).

What about this is intrinsically "dangerous nonsense"? Honestly, the "bitcoin bad" crowd so often loses me by conflating cryptocurrency - a ledger built on blockchain - with blockchain itself. Personally, I can see all the challenges faced by cryptocurrency and understand the skepticism, but these takes that write off blockchain due to cryptocurrencies' problems exhibit a sort of surface-level perspective that I can't take very seriously. And the fact that such shallow takes keep climbing to the top of HN is shameful, to say the least.

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by knorker on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:00AM (#31190671)
> I can see all the challenges faced by cryptocurrency and understand the skepticism, but these takes that write off blockchain due to cryptocurrencies' problems exhibit a sort of surface-level perspective that I can't take very seriously

I would agree, if there were any use for the blockchain or PoW.

It's dangerous nonsense because it's an industry consisting entirely of producing scams, with huge impact to the environment, availability of graphics cards, hard drives (thanks Bram Cohen), and free tiers of everything[1].

Even bandwidth has been turned into a get-rich-quick scheme! Waste bandwidth for coins! (Obvious result: increase in use of ISP transfer caps, and/or just a congested Internet for us all)

It's one stop short of "mine my new cryptocurrency by throwing away food". People will start stealing your food deliveries in order to throw them in the trash, for money.

That's the equivalent of what's happening whenever some blockchain-buzzword new scam is created, but in internet form.

So the fact that it ruins everything is why it's dangerous. It only creates problems, and only "solves" problems by the definition of "when I want to break the law then it's a problem that I'm not allowed to". That's why it's nonsense.

[1] You can't launch a free tier turing complete anything today without having ALL your resources be taken by freeloading cryptojerks. Like if your free online puzzle game was accidentally turing complete (or less, since that's not even a hard requirement) then someone somewhere will start burning all your quota and money calculating hashes.

Like if you make "the game of life" processed server side I'm sure someone will turn it into a bitcoin miner.

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by 5h on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:52AM (#31190607)
You've set yourself up for a question: Please give an example, with a deeper-lever perspective, of a real-world use-case for (non-crypto) blockchain that isn't better solved with non-blockchain technology.

Edit to answer this question:

> What about this is intrinsically "dangerous nonsense"?

The article isn't about the tech itself, it's about the interfaces of the tech and the real world. The problems there are shameless shilling, deception & efficiency problems.

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by z3c0 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:22AM (#31190806)
And you've set yourself up for an answer;)

I think any adversarial system has something to gain from blockchain. When participants of a system are naturally pitted against one another due to being competitors (a la engaging in a zero-sum game), the solution is usually to agree to auditing by a third-party. However, this method is easily corruptible by replacing the auditors with biased parties[1]. This is not an uncommon problem. Try searching "biased auditors", and you'll get a wealth of literature and perspectives on the issue.

A lot of blockchain proponents are majorly against the idea of "private blockchains", but I'm not. I believe private blockchains hold a lot of promise as a way of auditing an adversarial system, in place of a corruptible third-party. Plus, auditors don't amount to much more than middle-men, and thus add an additional layer of complexity to the system, meaning more can go wrong. Redirecting the cost of auditors to maintaining a system hosted by the adversaries would result in a more lean system (by less nodes) with little chance of bias corrupting the audit process (because you can't inject former employees into a blockchain). Instead of the SEC having to oversee both the members of the network and the auditors to prevent trusts from forming, they would just need to monitor the blockchain updates.

What the technical implementation of this would look like would vary wildly by industry, and thus would require some brainstorming to ensure feasibility, but no such brainstorming would ever begin if the members of an adversarial system are convinced that blockchains are "dangerous nonsense".

Of course, such a technology would take a massive chunk from a very profitable industry, so I expect a lot of people (employed auditors) to be averse to the idea, but maybe those people need to do some soul-searching. When your job depends on the continued existence of a problem, you aren't really incentivized to diminish the problem. Rape-whistle companies sell less rape-whistles if people rape less.

[1] https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/ernst-young-auditors-to-pay-...

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by FabHK on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:56AM (#31191020)
1. How do you solve the oracle problem? Blockchain can only deal with things that are on the blockchain already. Any interface to the real world suffers the trust and bias issues you described. You're just shifting the problem ever so slightly. (That's why the only real application is crypto currencies so far, because those can be realised wholly within the blockchain.)

2. How do you incentivise expending the PoW work without cryptocurrencies?

3. Why not have one central/permissioned authority issue chains of blocks, and everyone that wants can verify them cheaply? That is millions of times more efficient than PoW.

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by z3c0 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @08:31AM (#31191698)
All great questions, and I'll preface my response to saying that the true answers to these problems would have to be addressed in the "industry-specific brainstorming" that I mentioned. The results could look wildly different based on the problem the blockchain is addressing.

That said, the movement of "tangible assets" to "blockchain assets" is without a doubt a huge challenge for blockchains, but usually only when dealing with "real things" vs "systemic things", eg exchanging fiat for cryptocurrency. Integration into a private blockchain can be wholly systemic (so system-to-system vs reality-to-system). Integrating a new company into the system could be done by a joint effort between the members of private blockchain (who are all incentivized to help, because it's in their interest to ensure that no member of their industry goes unchecked.)

The economic incentive to commit to PoW is intrinsic to the adversarial network itself - basically, the desire of a company to survive the zero-sum game (success in such is typically measured by market share.)

To revert to a centralized authority is not an invalid approach, and may very well be the "happy medium" that allows this concept to solidify into something feasible. However, it is a "half-in, half-out" solution and is still vulnerable to corruption.

This is -of course - all speculative, but my overall point is that the discussion to reach solutions to these challenges will not be had if blockchains are written off as "dangerous nonsense".

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by 5h on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:35AM (#31191276)
Short comment to say I appreciate the thoughtful response here, and that implications of public vs private blockchains in real world contexts is something I've not given enough thought to - thanks for the homework :)
Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by jedimind on Thursday April 28, 2022 @05:56AM (#31190637)
"it is the only known solution to the Byzantine Generals problem that doesn't involve a centralized authority"

Did you skip that one on purpose? How do non-blockchain technologies solve the the Byzantine General's problem without relying on a (corrupt) central authority? Address this before you make more demands.

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by knorker on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:11AM (#31190744)
How does blockchain solve the Byzantine General's problem without relying on a (corrupt) central authority?

Math or not, police & courts overrule them.

Actually, blockchain isn't even mathematically a solution to BGP, is it? You need to define your actors better, here.

A 51% attack means communication can be denied. And there's still the question of how does A know that B has seen that A has seen, that B has seen…

Am I missing something?

The fact that communication happens on the blockchain doesn't mean it's not communication.

I just read a couple of articles about blockchain and BGP, and I think they all misunderstood what BGP is.

I'm A, and see that B is "committed on the blockchain to attack, assuming A is too". I can then add my block that says "I see B commits to attack. I agree let's both do this. I'll attack if you attack".

Ok. So now B sees that. Do they attack?

If you think the answer here is clear, then you've misunderstood BGP.

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by 5h on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:01AM (#31190675)
Good attempt at a deflection, I won't casually solve the very thing that is a great example of blockchain being a solution looking for a problem.

But, given the 'real world' context I tried to stress, do you think blockchain is a good solution to the variations of that problem in real world contexts?

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by jedimind on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:14AM (#31190766)
You think that you're onto something but your rhetoric and arguments honestly make me cringe.

People are increasingly aware that governments/authorities do not deserve the trust that they have been given + the opaque nature of the system only allows authorities to abuse their power. Thus the technology you love to hate so much does in fact serve "real world" problems and is more trusted, so much so that Ethereum for instance processes 4.5x more transactions than Visa [0].

There are many more arguments how this technology delivers real value to real people NOW, but I have no interest in entertaining more of this kind of bad faith discussions. The better technology will survive and eventually dominate, with or without you.

[0]: https://www.investing.com/news/cryptocurrency-news/ethereum-...

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by 5h on Thursday April 28, 2022 @07:29AM (#31191232)
I don't hate blockchain - the technology - it's really interesting.

Something I dislike though is that so many conversations that enquire roughly 'why not use a more traditional technology' end up with rant about not trusting governments - that is 'cringe'.

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by hudon on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:10AM (#31190730)
It does not solve the Byzantine Generals problem... This has been apparent since Satoshi had to fly in to communicate from a place of authority how the protocol should be fixed to address bugs. This happened again after Satoshi's departure in 2013 [0] where the Byzantine Generals had to meet in a chatroom and be the "trusted central party" that the rest of the stakeholders followed. Without the leaders of the space being able to communicate directly on the Internet, Bitcoin would be a confused mess, since it's never clear when the longest chain should be abandoned given the ambiguous nature of bugs/features.

[0] https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2015/07/28/analyzing-the-2013-...

Re:Blockchain Is Dangerous Nonsense by z3c0 on Thursday April 28, 2022 @06:30AM (#31190858)
I don't consider forking to be a problem, though it very frequently gets treated like it's some silver bullet to the blockchain concept. Forking is the democratic nature of the system at work. A few key players in the system are not the only "Generals" - everybody acting as a verification node is a General, and which fork they choose to follow is still a decision that they hold. Bitcoin being young and having hiccups prompted people to listen to the "expert generals", but this isn't a function of blockchains, just society overall. Collectively choosing to abandon a long chain in favor of a short chain based on the opinions of experts is a great solution to the permanence of blockchains, which poses its own challenges. Before this incident, it was believed that a blockchain had to be 100% correct upon initialization, and any software developer should realize how much of a pipe-dream that is.